Yeah, even though Trans people BARELY make sense in the real world, it makes NO sense in a fantasy and sci fi setting.
Why? Magic and tech
If you have the magic or the tech to transform your body at will, why the fuck would you be trans?! You want to be a girl, wave a wand, drink a potion or step into a medical station and boom, you are now a fully FUNCTIONAL woman. Same thing if you want to be a guy, be a cat girl, cyborg or even another race.
If you put trans in a fantasy setting, and I'm not just talking about 1 weird guy that loves to cross dress as that's always existed but an entire category, you are just an uncreative shallow writer.
If you have the magic or the tech to transform your body at will, why the fuck would you be trans?!
Because it's a degenerate fetish. "Trans" as defined by left doesn't exist. They're just cross dressing pedophiles who managed to gain enough clout to avoid the treatment pedophiles usually get.
Essentially, the few that MIGHT have a genuine mental issue that they feel mismatched in their own bodies aren't going to be saying trans rights, they're either in long term therapy or trying to not draw attention to themselves as they want to just be treated by the gender norms they associate with.
Which we had, Tomboy and Feminine guys existed and now anyone who fits those titles, the left immediately tries to drug and maim them.
The truly delusional ones need mental help. If a schitzo thinks that his toaster is telling him to kill people we don't validate those delusions, we make sure that he isn't a danger to society and ideally treat him so the delusions go away. Troonery should be treated no differently. Of course, those numbers will go way down if we ever get serious about preventing that sick cult from grooming people into thinking that they're the opposite sex to begin with.
Very true, it's just a shame the very institution of psychology was co-opted too long ago by malicious parties that it's barely scratched the surface still to help these mentally ill people. We are talking about an institution that considered lobotomy and electro-shock therapy the future of mentally health.
If technology was ever developed that could absolutely turn people into the opposite sex perfectly, and give them all the right looks, organs, biological processes, and DNA, the trannies will be the most outspoken against it.
It could make for a good story, in the "what were they smoking?" school of anime style stories. Some guy has bad autogynephelia, and so clones himself as a woman, with his memories intact, but he creates the "perfect" body, and so its brain is better-formed, and isn't damaged and have such mental conditions, even if it has memory of them. And so the new body has no interest in the old one, nor in fulfilling any fantasies thereof, but has been afflicted with actual dysphoria thanks to the original's selfish fetish, that can't be fixed because tech is at "grow from scratch", not "alter existing" levels. From that base, you could go horror, romcom, slice of life, even action, based on how the two interact.
Damn that went dark, would be an interesting story but I'd need a nice slice of life to not be depressed after lol
I have seen some lighter anime on the topic of when a bro is turned into a chick and then they go on a quest to turn them back as they don't want to answer the madding question:
If you best bro is turned into a fully functioning woman, is it gay to marry them as you now have your best friend who has the physical benefits of a woman but none of the negative behaviours (I joke, kinda).
I don't think they hate HP, just Rowling. And that's kind of what they do anyways: take original ideas from "loathsome" creators and mash in alphabets and race-swaps, then claim ownership of the IP.
Harry Potter was a foundational part of their personalities, but Rowling only buys in to 95% of the progressive agenda and that's completely intolerable.
For example: Lovecraft. They take any opportunity they can to tell you how horrible he is, yet they continue to use his work as inspiration constantly.
In a universe that has polyjuice potion, and it can canonically transform you into a person of the opposite sex, there'd be absolutely no reason for trans people to exist.
Isn't that an implicit admission that even they acknowledge that transmen aren't men and transwomen aren't women? Because if transwomen are women (as the saying goes) then they'd just choose a woman avatar and move on with their lives.
The death of every character and the ultimate victory of no nosed macgee so that instead of a story about school safety hazards we could have a much more interesting one.
Also the destruction of all information and artifacts related to time magic.......only using it to attend classes.....sigh
Voldemort started as a boy but, through the power of the blackest magic, ripped his soul into pieces and transcended his physical body into one of a sexless freak in a quest for power.
The evil house would be the rare straight, normal people who somehow become wizards despite almost all wizards being trans
Everything else is the same until the end
Instead of having a time skip for the last chapter of the last book, it talks about the mental hospital Hogwarts and you realize it's all a drug-addled dream of Harriet, projecting her fantasies on the other people / staff there.
You need a better dnd group. Our group used a sex change potion to turn a hobgoblin king into a female, stripped off all "her" clothes and left "her" to die in an alleyway knowing that no one would believe that this nude hobgoblin lady was once a hobgoblin king, all this just to humiliate him. We've also committed a couple of genocides.
Never once do these "people" look at someone "who's the same gender as them" and think "that's me". It's not enough for a tranny to look at a woman and think "yes, that is me". It needs to be a "trans woman".
So, no. Trans women aren't women. Because they don't see themselves as women.
What the fuck do they even mean by 'trans' people at this point?
There's potions and spells in harry potter that let you shapeshift into almost anything you want, as far as the franchise is concerned some of the characters might not be what they appear already.
If they mean 'trans' as in degenerate pedophile creeps with rotting axe-wounds between their legs, what does the franchise have to gain from that?
I feel like I don't even need to ask you this, but what's your opinion on Dragonflight? I haven't bought it and don't plan to, and I've noticed that like 50% of the NPC's are now queer. There's even gay frogs.
It pisses me off to no end. The game I once loved is now a Sodomite shithole. If Microsoft actually does end up buying Blizzard, they should just set the franchise on fire and rewrite everything.
I would make every single greentext about harry potter canon.
Also the funniest thing about this post is that even if they could make trannies canon in the wizarding world, they would still be mentally hill losers in the real world.
Yep, we don't have the magic or tech required to transform someone into the opposite sex. A game of "emperor's new clothes" is REQUIRED for transgenderism to work with our current barbaric reassignments and it is not sustainable to inflict such dishonesty on a population. It is truly a disservice to people with gender dysphoria that they're told that this is the only solution and cruel to say that it is a guaranteed fix. Have you ever read anything from detrans people?
Yeah, even though Trans people BARELY make sense in the real world, it makes NO sense in a fantasy and sci fi setting.
Why? Magic and tech
If you have the magic or the tech to transform your body at will, why the fuck would you be trans?! You want to be a girl, wave a wand, drink a potion or step into a medical station and boom, you are now a fully FUNCTIONAL woman. Same thing if you want to be a guy, be a cat girl, cyborg or even another race.
If you put trans in a fantasy setting, and I'm not just talking about 1 weird guy that loves to cross dress as that's always existed but an entire category, you are just an uncreative shallow writer.
Because it's a degenerate fetish. "Trans" as defined by left doesn't exist. They're just cross dressing pedophiles who managed to gain enough clout to avoid the treatment pedophiles usually get.
Essentially, the few that MIGHT have a genuine mental issue that they feel mismatched in their own bodies aren't going to be saying trans rights, they're either in long term therapy or trying to not draw attention to themselves as they want to just be treated by the gender norms they associate with.
Which we had, Tomboy and Feminine guys existed and now anyone who fits those titles, the left immediately tries to drug and maim them.
The truly delusional ones need mental help. If a schitzo thinks that his toaster is telling him to kill people we don't validate those delusions, we make sure that he isn't a danger to society and ideally treat him so the delusions go away. Troonery should be treated no differently. Of course, those numbers will go way down if we ever get serious about preventing that sick cult from grooming people into thinking that they're the opposite sex to begin with.
Very true, it's just a shame the very institution of psychology was co-opted too long ago by malicious parties that it's barely scratched the surface still to help these mentally ill people. We are talking about an institution that considered lobotomy and electro-shock therapy the future of mentally health.
They’re “trans” all right. TRANSvestites.
If technology was ever developed that could absolutely turn people into the opposite sex perfectly, and give them all the right looks, organs, biological processes, and DNA, the trannies will be the most outspoken against it.
That or they would be even more upset that men and women still only want to date naturally born men or women
Kinda like how feminists are against sex robots and artificial wombs, they lose their only card to play for political and social capital.
A lot of people on this win will hate me for saying this, but...
If what you describe ever actually happens, and is repeatedly proven to actually work...
I would 100% endorse it. That would be amazing.
But you're also right that they'll hate it. They don't want to stop THE STRUGGLE.
They are deranged. They need to be put in a nuthouse.
It could make for a good story, in the "what were they smoking?" school of anime style stories. Some guy has bad autogynephelia, and so clones himself as a woman, with his memories intact, but he creates the "perfect" body, and so its brain is better-formed, and isn't damaged and have such mental conditions, even if it has memory of them. And so the new body has no interest in the old one, nor in fulfilling any fantasies thereof, but has been afflicted with actual dysphoria thanks to the original's selfish fetish, that can't be fixed because tech is at "grow from scratch", not "alter existing" levels. From that base, you could go horror, romcom, slice of life, even action, based on how the two interact.
Damn that went dark, would be an interesting story but I'd need a nice slice of life to not be depressed after lol
I have seen some lighter anime on the topic of when a bro is turned into a chick and then they go on a quest to turn them back as they don't want to answer the madding question:
If you best bro is turned into a fully functioning woman, is it gay to marry them as you now have your best friend who has the physical benefits of a woman but none of the negative behaviours (I joke, kinda).
They do not despise it, they want to conquer it.
That is kind of their modus operandi with everything
And now I'm sad because the "Moldus operandi" joke falls flat since in the English original version it's "Muggles".
They want to make us despise it. Infiltrate and destroy is their modus operandi.
What raging narcissist doesn't imagine themselves with magic powers?
I don't think they hate HP, just Rowling. And that's kind of what they do anyways: take original ideas from "loathsome" creators and mash in alphabets and race-swaps, then claim ownership of the IP.
Harry Potter was a foundational part of their personalities, but Rowling only buys in to 95% of the progressive agenda and that's completely intolerable.
Exactly. This all started Rowling commented on the "people who menstrate" phrase. It shouldn't have been controversial but her fans are too sensitive.
For example: Lovecraft. They take any opportunity they can to tell you how horrible he is, yet they continue to use his work as inspiration constantly.
In a universe that has polyjuice potion, and it can canonically transform you into a person of the opposite sex, there'd be absolutely no reason for trans people to exist.
Isn't that an implicit admission that even they acknowledge that transmen aren't men and transwomen aren't women? Because if transwomen are women (as the saying goes) then they'd just choose a woman avatar and move on with their lives.
Of course, but they're mentally retarded narcissists - there is no logic.
lol that's hilarious.
The death of every character and the ultimate victory of no nosed macgee so that instead of a story about school safety hazards we could have a much more interesting one.
Also the destruction of all information and artifacts related to time magic.......only using it to attend classes.....sigh
Voldemort started as a boy but, through the power of the blackest magic, ripped his soul into pieces and transcended his physical body into one of a sexless freak in a quest for power.
So trans people are already cannonical.
Make pretty much all wizards trans
The evil house would be the rare straight, normal people who somehow become wizards despite almost all wizards being trans
Everything else is the same until the end
Instead of having a time skip for the last chapter of the last book, it talks about the mental hospital Hogwarts and you realize it's all a drug-addled dream of Harriet, projecting her fantasies on the other people / staff there.
It’s the same as the Mary Sue who can keep up with men, they need to feed their delusion so they can pretend that is reality.
Wait, dont they have potions and spells that make a perfect transformation between genders?
Of course positing that got me kicked out of a d&d group and I dont expect much in the way of a constructive response here either.
They do.
Harry Potter not only has both short and long-term gender-switching potions, they can also shapechange into their fursonas at will.
You need a better dnd group. Our group used a sex change potion to turn a hobgoblin king into a female, stripped off all "her" clothes and left "her" to die in an alleyway knowing that no one would believe that this nude hobgoblin lady was once a hobgoblin king, all this just to humiliate him. We've also committed a couple of genocides.
Bruh its 1990s Ingerland the only troons the average limey is seeing are in The Crying Game
Never once do these "people" look at someone "who's the same gender as them" and think "that's me". It's not enough for a tranny to look at a woman and think "yes, that is me". It needs to be a "trans woman".
So, no. Trans women aren't women. Because they don't see themselves as women.
What the fuck do they even mean by 'trans' people at this point?
There's potions and spells in harry potter that let you shapeshift into almost anything you want, as far as the franchise is concerned some of the characters might not be what they appear already.
If they mean 'trans' as in degenerate pedophile creeps with rotting axe-wounds between their legs, what does the franchise have to gain from that?
I really wish Blizzard fucked off with Troonery. It makes NO sense in WoW, or in ANY other media.
I feel like I don't even need to ask you this, but what's your opinion on Dragonflight? I haven't bought it and don't plan to, and I've noticed that like 50% of the NPC's are now queer. There's even gay frogs.
It pisses me off to no end. The game I once loved is now a Sodomite shithole. If Microsoft actually does end up buying Blizzard, they should just set the franchise on fire and rewrite everything.
I would make every single greentext about harry potter canon.
Also the funniest thing about this post is that even if they could make trannies canon in the wizarding world, they would still be mentally hill losers in the real world.
A troon or troon minion expressing a narcissistic opinion.
I'm shocked and appalled.
final solution to the tranny question
By “canonical” do they mean loading them all into a giant fuckin cannon, because I would support this.
In a world where there are potions that can change your appearance to basically whatever you want, not even magic can make you a woman.
people?
Yep, we don't have the magic or tech required to transform someone into the opposite sex. A game of "emperor's new clothes" is REQUIRED for transgenderism to work with our current barbaric reassignments and it is not sustainable to inflict such dishonesty on a population. It is truly a disservice to people with gender dysphoria that they're told that this is the only solution and cruel to say that it is a guaranteed fix. Have you ever read anything from detrans people?