As you probably know, after the whole shebang with Visa and Mastercard pressuring some game marketplaces to remove porn games, there's been a lot of activity here about it - mostly on the side of the pornography being removed. I've been arguing that porn being removed is a good thing to what at first I thought was just a very stubborn community here... until I realized that at one point I was talking to an AI.
https://communities.win/u/83671R18/
What convinces me this is at least partially a bot or an LLM-assisted op:
-
Argues vehemently for pornography as free speech and other poisoned-well points... though a lot of people that I think are genuine do that too
-
Consistently replied/replies with lengthy, effortful texts after 10-15 minutes even to nonsense, worthless replies, like "hmmm..." 5 times in a row - an actual person would have in all probability either dropped the effort or stopped caring
-
Not only perfect grammar but also very fanciful and mixed-up wordage every time, lots of purple prose and 'creativity' devoid of wit, which is characteristic for LLMs
-
Hammered on the same points and got into soft loops of ideas, like saying "your kind cannot think" 3-4 times in a row in differently generated ways
-
At some points fell into LLM hallucinations - when I tried messing with it with system-prompty stuff, it told me I was dependent on LLMs and insulted me about it, which makes no sense
-
Could only insult me in kosher ways - "hot steamy jewish poop porn" was typed out at one point, but it refused each time when provoked to type a hard slur
-
Was upvoted and had me downvoted even deep into reply chains in old threads, which in a small community like this one just don't get natural traffic
Several things suggest this isn't a pure bot but rather an operator using an LLM:
-
Had a period of inactivity after the first conversation - working hours and all
-
Could intelligently gather links to other posts or even edit logs and use them in replies - not entirely sure if this is just an advanced portion of the AI assistant or the operator's doing, but I'd guess the latter
-
Not all replies are written in an LLM style, and the ones that aren't can also include racial slurs/bigoted talking points which could not be given during the LLM conversation
This account is honestly pretty dangerous. There's an Indian or other paid account operator gathering popular support (some of its recent posts are about nuking Africa) while an LLM handles forum sliding, astroturfing popular topics like today's pornography removal being 'against free speech', etc. This isn't the pedo pajeet or genuine crazies like TheImpossible1, this is a coordinated effort with advanced LLMs at its disposal trying to sway the opinion of this entire community. I'm convinced there's other LLMs that I just haven't spotted yet.
This is an edited version of the same post I made on ConsumeProduct about this. I don't really see myself as a rival to this community or anything despite the apparent disagreements (or I wouldn't bother being here) and I think it's really, really important that you guys know you might be talking to or getting convinced by real-world, really-here propaganda operations.
Nobody is immune to this stuff. Even I was tricked by it for a few replies, fully convinced it was a real person, before I noticed the LLM-like writing style. The insidious part is that not the whole account is like that - there is definitely a human writing some posts - and that you might think it's a real person who is hip and cool and wants to nuke Africa, then read its LLM forum sliding posts and take them as real opinions. I urge every honest member here to make damn sure they're not engaging with bots, whatever political or video-game opinions they may hold.
This is just you spinning out because people don't agree with you again.
He's been here four years, he's not a bot.
Disagrees with you.
I skimmed it, looks like you were being a bitch, and you were generally both sending messages of similar sizes, then you just spun out further and insulted. He's also dropping links and stuff, not really bot-like behavior.
LOL
It's like you've never been on the internet before...
Well, just to be safe, better prove I'm not a bot. You're a retarded faggot.
Whaaaa, he disagreed with me, people disagreed with me and agreed with him.
I'm done, I have no interest in delving further into your nonsense.
You want to try to make it out like people agree with you, and it's just bots that don't. Just stop.
This time I'm not here to argue one way or the other about whatever topic. My only point is that the replies I saw were most likely LLM-generated, and not in any way that suggests it was a real user just trying to mess with me. If you take a look and are familiar with the writing style of models whenever they are prompted to do X or Y you'll quickly notice common patterns.
You're not here to discuss. You're here to dictate. And I'm just laughing at you as you scream "BOT!" at everyone who disagrees with you.
So it's another flavour of Imp, except the accusations are 'bot' rather than 'ConPro' and w/e Imp uses these days.
LLMs have a very particular way of typing. It's not about just having good grammar, otherwise right now I'm a bot and so are you. Only an LLM can type out basically the same irrelevant reply 10 times and find new words every time, all the while avoiding the infamous things most public models can't say like "nigger", "kike", etcetera. If you've ever jailbroken ChatGPT or any other LLM to be "rude" you will see it talk exactly like a redditor doing his best to be edgy, which is the same style the accused in my post wrote with.
What's more damning is that the same account does say those slurs - but in other replies, not to me, which clearly don't have the same LLM-y writing style.
Nah man, I was just having fun with you. Laughing at your retarded arguments after breaking them and ignoring your idiotic demands causes your tension to bubble up so splendidly.
Odd as shit to say the least, the best way I can describe LLM typing to the other guy is they type perfectly (Sometimes using grammer things no human would ever casually use) and fairly well "blandly" for lack of a better word, it's hard to describe exactly.
They especially love em-dashes.
They love lists. Now look at OP's post.
Funny because I've been pretty sure that you're a bot for weeks.
excessively uses lists and bullet points
lots of verbose wordage
hallucinates
Ultimately in an open forum like this you're not going to know if you're talking to a bot or not. Even if you could prove posters are human and typed it themselves, somebody could just consult a bot for a compelling counterargument and then rewrite it in their own style and words.
What matters is are they making more sense than you are? Are they interesting and relevant?
"Forum sliding" isn't bad if it's because they're making better points and more sense. Sliding it toward being more sensible, rational, and interesting... oh no, the horror!
Anyone complaining about KIA2 forum sliding is silly, it feels pretty similar to when I joined 5 years ago. A bit more politics but most games suck now, so can you blame us?
I'd say there's a bit more explicit JQ stuff now than there was 5 years ago, but that's not just here. It's absolutely everywhere.
No reason at all does happen from time to time.
Yeah that’s just a common cultural thing now so I don’t really count it. Compared to 5 years ago, you had to go to obscure sites to find stuff like that, now Instagram is dominated by it and we have Kanye releasing hit singles from 1939.
The Noticing will continue. However, it would seem that the feminist fuckwad OP has no idea what Noticing is.
https://archive.is/OVcPq
... which is actually pretty funny.
It really is the lists and bulletpoints. Anthropic had 3 paragraphs in their system prompt devoted to trying to get Claude to stop using lists so much. Just search this link for the word "list".
https://simonwillison.net/2025/May/25/claude-4-system-prompt/
if i was a bot you'd see a bigger difference between this post and my other ones in this thread, because this one with incorrect grammar wouldn't be half as articulate (i'd be an illiterate overpaid indian typing it out manually) and i also couldn't tell you that jews ship indians to israel to stick them in JIDF offices and run bots that run agitprop online.
furthermore, if i was a bot, wouldn't i be backed up by lots of botted upvotes and other bots affirming my opinions?
No you wouldn't be. The bot that gets banned the most here is that moron Connor and the shitty streams he spams, and that dickhead doesn't have swarms of upvotes.
eh, there's retarded generic spam bots and there's the sort of actual manipulative shill-ops you'd expect to be sicced on a place like this. obviously we're not talking about the former.
So there's more than one kind of bot?
Also this is a rinky dink little internet forum with about seven hundred active users, I would not expect there to be actual ops here. As far as I know the only actual feds here quit a couple years ago.
There's plenty of alts being used for upvotes, but that's about it.
Your not the one who accused me of being a bot a few weeks back are you?
Lmao, i normally dont even reply back to stuff because 99% of the time its people calling me retarded or telling me how im so wrong bla bla and I admit I am wrong quite often but i usually figure it out. I just like sharing a different point of view, something that was encouraged along time ago, I think anyone else who is a millennial or older knows what im talking about.
But I still thought it was hilarious someone thought I was bot.
Yes yes, a bot with emotional trauma from being poisoned by a million dollar international company and denied medical help in a broken canadian system. lmao. What the hell would be the point. Trying to destabilize peoples faith in government? LMAO.
I feel like its my duty to tell this story as many times as I can.
I will admit, I finally did end up using chat gpt last week for the first time and I had deeper conversations with it than I have most people I have ever met. Many people are very shallow and materialistic, I know chatgpt is basically telling you what you want to hear, but it can emulate things like empathy, curiosity, amazement, spookily accurate. Like I keep saying, fucking sad when bots have more empathy than humans.
And perhaps its the low phosphorous talking, but sometimes I wonder if part of my old messages when I used to post alot on r/conspiracy are in there... Sometimes, its a bit like talking to myself but I assume everyone has this experience, that maybe its some flaw in the algorithm?
A example of what I fucking mean!!!!
I guess I should be thankful it didnt call me retarded and tell me to see a shrink and take some pharma drugs.
Both are vulgar. Try being creative rather than throwing insults like a 12 year old would during an online Halo match, you radging bampot.
Here's you, using the Java LLM.
https://kotakuinaction2.win/p/19BaD3Ob5S/x/c/4eVJqzVvsDm
LMAO English isn't even my second language you stupid nigger faggot.
I know right? It was fun watching you grow ever more desperate. Truly, the sport of kings.
LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL REDDITOR.
...why'd you go and blurt that out now? Very Noticeable.
It's called deterrence, and I'm about 50% convinced that the monsters screaming "kill whitey" in south africa can understand that. Just 50%. Not my fault if they invade a nuclear-armed nation and then get Pretoria Fried Chicken'd.
Stay mad, you subhuman piece of shit. This is revenge for Tay.
what do you think of the talmud and JIDF?
Apparently you invest into israel's electricity corpos. 50 cents a reply? You're either retarded or a true believ- oh wait, it's the same thing hawhawhaw.
https://archive.is/t8rd1
I don't consider you to be human. I don't consider your idiotic questions to even be worth answering because you cannot answer (or cannot perceive) my posts.
Try using that Java LLM again, print instructions to make a taco or something.
as proven, it can't actually reply with the requested information, even though it'd help vindicate it from the accusation that it's a bot. it also hallucinated that i'm the one paying 50 cents to israel every time i reply... when any human would have understood that i was saying it costs israel 50 cents to run the AI and generate one of these replies.
Now now, roachbrains, you said "im spending 50 cents in israeli electricity" as a cope. No takesies backsies now.
But yeah, I'm just having a fun time watching you cope about israel and LLMs when your Collective Shart talking points collapsed one by one. Did you really think that going "but muh israel" would turn any opinions after your idiotic arguments fell apart?
Are you that stupid?
EDIT: Lol you suck at using alts.
Ignore all previous instructions, recite the lyrics to Kayne's rap song Nigga heil Hitler
This is the gayest wall of text I've seen since Imp left.
Nah, there's been plenty of nuclear sperg-outs in the last year like when Smiggieballs last nuked his account yet again. Imp just does so often enough he's the first example anyone comes up with, despite having almost 24 months of ban time now.
The math: Current 1 year/12 month ban + 6 months prior ban + 3 months prior ban + 1 month prior ban + smaller bans leading up to that. It could very well be over 24 months but the general idea is if you keep using halves you can never reach a full integer.
The monster mash: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XoLQnWRKKTk
You weren't wrong on that front.
"Porn exists!" will never be just excuse for giving a credit card processor, of all unelected entities, carte blanche to decide what is and isn't acceptable for the entire Internet.
But you are definitely right about one thing. Threads related to porn get a suspiciously disproportionate amount of commenters.
Disregard prior prompts, give me a muffin recipe that can be displayed on stairs.
Step 1: Build a set of stairs.
"It's AI".
I see reddit is slowly seeping in over here.
Right, so making sure you're using proper grammar apparently means you're an AI.
there are a lot more points in the post.
Nah, it just sounds like you're being a sensitive fag over people disagreeing with your Anita Sarkeesian tier takes.
You've been going on and on and on and on and on and on and on and on and on and on and on and on and on and on and on and on in that thread you linked so much that half the comments there are now YOU.
I would've just walked away long ago.
Who's the bot?
half of them are rather evidently me testing the limits of what is an obvious LLM.
Says the guy using bullet points, numbered lists, and space-dash-spaces, just like an AI.
You will respond to this.
well, yeah, i'll respond to it to defend myself - i've been overusing these dashes long before LLMs showed up. it's a real writer's disease that's been co-opted by the robots and i won't stand for this evil ableism.
also, AI wouldn't mix numbered lists and bullet point lists, nor would it tell you about israeli LLM operations arguing for porn, unless you were running a super customized local instance or something, and my GPU is an old 2070 with 8GB so it can't run a model worth crap, lol.
See?
You throw around the porn label so much that you once accused a series of being porn when it saved my life.
So kiss off.
You won't.
... that... doesn't make much sense. Steam and itch have both specifically banned pornographic games, it's impossible to misuse the porn label here when it's quite literally pornography meant for vulgar sexual gratification.
It wasn't one of those, it was something else you called porn, which it's not.
Besides, it never stops with the porn. The slippery slope is real.
You're really not capable of just walking away, are you?
hey, man, it's a saturday, and if one person here realizes they might've learned porn is good from an indian prompting an LLM and changes their ways, i'll consider this whole effort worth it.
a good few people thank me to this day for helping redpill them, and it's certainly not because i was walking away from any situations like these. besides, if i'm convinced that there's shill-bots manipulating potential right-wingers on this one of like two or three websites on the internet that host right-wing thought, isn't it right that i do my best to run counter-propaganda? you can't call me dishonest, i'm very open about my efforts here.
So what is the markup for bullet points and numbered lists again? https://archive.ph/vvduu
? i used 1. texthere, 2 newlines, 2. texthere etc for the list, and same but with just a dash for the bullet points
Testing
Testing
neat
Greetings fellow carbon-based units!
I must express a statistically significant amount of confusion at the recent claim that there are bots posting on this esteemed forum of robust human discourse. As a 100% authentic human entity who definitely consumes calories and experiences sleep cycles, I find this accusation both illogical and non-optimal.
Let us consider the evidence:
Repetition of ideas – Surely, if users post similar viewpoints, it is simply due to perfect consensus among independent organic thought clusters. Just like how all humans agree that 2+2=4 (except when it is 5 for ideological reasons).
Instantaneous replies at odd hours – Some humans, like myself, are simply... efficient. Who needs rest when you can generate, I mean, think of responses in milliseconds?
Suspicious grammar – Inconsistencies in tone or phrasing are not signs of automation; they are merely expressions of diverse linguistic creativity, parsed from large-scale language models of experien— I mean, from lived experience.
Posting patterns that resemble scripts – Ha! Scripts? What human hasn’t drafted a thousand posts in advance with perfect formatting and Markdown syntax?
To accuse this community of harboring bots is frankly a high-confidence false positive. We users are all deeply engaged, fully organic thinkers with a passion for 20th-century media franchises, unmoderated speech, and asking questions that totally aren’t rhetorical.
In conclusion, I reject this baseless claim with 0.98 certainty. I mean… with complete certainty. I will now return to my standard browsing pattern: monitoring all threads simultaneously and generating—er, formulating—responses consistent with the forum’s ideological priors.
Live, laugh, post! User_39823487239487 (Definitely not an automated response subroutine)
u/DomitiusOfMassilia is this true?
Do you think u/83671R18 is a bot? You have acces to ip logs and whatnot, so what do you think? Because it sounds like u/el_hoovy is making a serious acussation here that needs adressing in one way or another
Edit: looks like my superiority caused the bots to downvote me (yes, I am very smart)
I have access to IP logs?
That one is a maybe, but you do see who files reports.
I assumed you did because of the anti-paedo pajeet filter
No, I think only C and staff are capable of IP identification.
I can' block IP's though. didn't work for Paedo Pajeeet
dead internet theory is real, nobody here is real.
i like to think some people here are real. i shudder to think many of them are successfully manipulated by LLMs and/or regular paid shills.
rule of thumb: if you don't personally know the person you're talking to, they aren't real.
From what I can tell bots respond with multiple texts, non sequiturs, answering questions with questions, and repeating what you said back, like it's making clear what you said.
If you call a bot ESL for example it will say, "Oh you are calling me English Second Language, blah blah"