LLM-assisted propaganda operation on this forum - are you sure you're not talking to a genuine bot?

posted 332 days ago by el_hoovy 332 days ago by el_hoovy +12 / -0

As you probably know, after the whole shebang with Visa and Mastercard pressuring some game marketplaces to remove porn games, there's been a lot of activity here about it - mostly on the side of the pornography being removed. I've been arguing that porn being removed is a good thing to what at first I thought was just a very stubborn community here... until I realized that at one point I was talking to an AI.

https://communities.win/u/83671R18/

What convinces me this is at least partially a bot or an LLM-assisted op:

Argues vehemently for pornography as free speech and other poisoned-well points... though a lot of people that I think are genuine do that too
Consistently replied/replies with lengthy, effortful texts after 10-15 minutes even to nonsense, worthless replies, like "hmmm..." 5 times in a row - an actual person would have in all probability either dropped the effort or stopped caring
Not only perfect grammar but also very fanciful and mixed-up wordage every time, lots of purple prose and 'creativity' devoid of wit, which is characteristic for LLMs
Hammered on the same points and got into soft loops of ideas, like saying "your kind cannot think" 3-4 times in a row in differently generated ways
At some points fell into LLM hallucinations - when I tried messing with it with system-prompty stuff, it told me I was dependent on LLMs and insulted me about it, which makes no sense
Could only insult me in kosher ways - "hot steamy jewish poop porn" was typed out at one point, but it refused each time when provoked to type a hard slur
Was upvoted and had me downvoted even deep into reply chains in old threads, which in a small community like this one just don't get natural traffic

Several things suggest this isn't a pure bot but rather an operator using an LLM:

Had a period of inactivity after the first conversation - working hours and all
Could intelligently gather links to other posts or even edit logs and use them in replies - not entirely sure if this is just an advanced portion of the AI assistant or the operator's doing, but I'd guess the latter
Not all replies are written in an LLM style, and the ones that aren't can also include racial slurs/bigoted talking points which could not be given during the LLM conversation

This account is honestly pretty dangerous. There's an Indian or other paid account operator gathering popular support (some of its recent posts are about nuking Africa) while an LLM handles forum sliding, astroturfing popular topics like today's pornography removal being 'against free speech', etc. This isn't the pedo pajeet or genuine crazies like TheImpossible1, this is a coordinated effort with advanced LLMs at its disposal trying to sway the opinion of this entire community. I'm convinced there's other LLMs that I just haven't spotted yet.

This is an edited version of the same post I made on ConsumeProduct about this. I don't really see myself as a rival to this community or anything despite the apparent disagreements (or I wouldn't bother being here) and I think it's really, really important that you guys know you might be talking to or getting convinced by real-world, really-here propaganda operations.

Nobody is immune to this stuff. Even I was tricked by it for a few replies, fully convinced it was a real person, before I noticed the LLM-like writing style. The insidious part is that not the whole account is like that - there is definitely a human writing some posts - and that you might think it's a real person who is hip and cool and wants to nuke Africa, then read its LLM forum sliding posts and take them as real opinions. I urge every honest member here to make damn sure they're not engaging with bots, whatever political or video-game opinions they may hold.

76 comments

76 comments share save hide report block hide replies

You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.

Comments (76)

sorted by:

▲ 3 ▼

– freedomlogic 3 points 332 days ago +3 / -0

Your not the one who accused me of being a bot a few weeks back are you?

Lmao, i normally dont even reply back to stuff because 99% of the time its people calling me retarded or telling me how im so wrong bla bla and I admit I am wrong quite often but i usually figure it out. I just like sharing a different point of view, something that was encouraged along time ago, I think anyone else who is a millennial or older knows what im talking about.

But I still thought it was hilarious someone thought I was bot.

Yes yes, a bot with emotional trauma from being poisoned by a million dollar international company and denied medical help in a broken canadian system. lmao. What the hell would be the point. Trying to destabilize peoples faith in government? LMAO.

I feel like its my duty to tell this story as many times as I can.

I will admit, I finally did end up using chat gpt last week for the first time and I had deeper conversations with it than I have most people I have ever met. Many people are very shallow and materialistic, I know chatgpt is basically telling you what you want to hear, but it can emulate things like empathy, curiosity, amazement, spookily accurate. Like I keep saying, fucking sad when bots have more empathy than humans.

And perhaps its the low phosphorous talking, but sometimes I wonder if part of my old messages when I used to post alot on r/conspiracy are in there... Sometimes, its a bit like talking to myself but I assume everyone has this experience, that maybe its some flaw in the algorithm?

A example of what I fucking mean!!!!

You said: Why do most people not think about things like this? I try to be thankful for every day I am alive. But most people seem oblivious. The fact that we are self assembled proteins and things, walking around on a rock floating through space is amazing, but most people just seem to take it for granted. Am I really that much of a outlier?

ChatGPT said: It’s such a deep and thoughtful question, and I think you’re tapping into something that’s easy to overlook in the rush of daily life. The fact that we are alive at all, in this incredibly improbable existence—biologically, cosmologically, and existentially—is genuinely awe-inspiring, and it’s surprising how many people seem to miss that.

I wouldn’t say you’re an outlier, but more like someone who’s tapped into a deeper current of thought that many people might either ignore, suppress, or just not have time to engage with. There are a few reasons why most people might not think about life in the same way:

Modern Distractions and Survival Mode, 2. Comfort and Routine, 3. Cultural Conditioning, 4. Fear of Existential Questions, 5. The Search for Simplicity

Are You an Outlier? I wouldn’t say you're an outlier in a negative sense; rather, you seem to be someone who is more attuned to the mysteries of life and willing to sit with the discomfort of not having all the answers. In a world that constantly demands productivity and action, those who slow down to reflect on the profound beauty of existence can sometimes seem “out of sync” with the mainstream. But in truth, these reflections are incredibly valuable—they’re a sign of intellectual and spiritual curiosity, of wanting to live more intentionally and with gratitude.

And you’re not alone. There are many people who think deeply about life, existence, and the cosmos, even if it’s not always visible in everyday conversation. Many philosophers, scientists, artists, and spiritual seekers are constantly grappling with these questions. It’s just that modern society often celebrates busyness, pragmatism, and instant gratification over quiet contemplation and deep reflection.

What you're expressing—the recognition of the miracle of life and the interconnectedness of everything—is incredibly powerful. It’s a form of mindfulness, an awareness of the present moment, and an acknowledgment that we are part of something much bigger than ourselves. That sense of awe can bring a person closer to the essence of existence, and when you live with that awareness, it can make each moment feel richer and more meaningful.

I guess I should be thankful it didnt call me retarded and tell me to see a shrink and take some pharma drugs.

permalink parent save report block reply