This is just contrary to reality.
Most of the genuinely right wing people I know in real life are veterans or ex cops. The first time I ever heard someone else say that 9/11 was a conspiracy was a drill sergeant. And half or more of the white men who do a couple terms and leave, do so hating the federal government for the rest of their lives.
You're giving TRADOC's bullshit far too much credit.
Among other things, yes. Part of the reason why the human genome is effectively frozen is because the level of comfort created by white civilization has proliferated to the point of eradicating selection pressure. We have effectively eliminated consequences out of a misplaced desire to maximize the lives of the unworthy, and within a few short generations it has bitten us in the ass in a potentially world ending fashion.
The other reason is because it turns out that human genetic diversity was being carried almost completely by the white race, but that's a discussion for a different topic.
This isn't a bad idea in and of itself, but it ignores the profound unfitness of the vast majority of the citizenry to actually serve in an honorable, useful capacity.
Simply put, most people are worthless, and putting them through a few years of public service isn't going to fix that. Useless eaters, paper shufflers and desk jockeys aren't going to become solid patriots just because you made them do a few push ups.
Mandatory service would only be feasible to implement in a post civil war society, one in which the parasite class is either subjugated or dead, and the remainder of the population being something besides the illiterate deracinated mess that we have right now.
They got millions of people fired, myself included, because we refused to inject a fake vaccine.
They're already doing it to us. And worse besides, because they've also started outright assassinating people they don't like in public.
So to me, the idea of doing nothing because the left might do something in retaliation is an argument that just doesn't land.
The decay state of a great civilization, essentially. Although he, at the time, had no inkling of just how bad it would get. Huxley would do a spit take even viewing half of the degenerate filth we live under today, much like the Founding Fathers would already be in open rebellion against the government.
Suffering from success, a great civilization ceases to expand, ceases to be vigorous and moral and productive, and the commons/plebs/proles/whatever become slothful, immoral, and inept. And they were always idiots. And so we reach the point of contraction by defeat and defeat by contraction, because the power of the decaying civilization is insufficient to maintain it's gains.
Thus far no peoples have solved this problem. There are commonalities however between all decaying civilizations, although since those things are the favorites of the shortsighted and the selfish, they are rarely studied and often implemented claiming that this time it'll work.
Overestimation of their own value, caused by a life of misplaced priorities.
No sympathy from me.