SURPRISE! Adobe's Firefly AI Image Generation is Anti-White & Racist
(media.scored.co)
Comments (31)
sorted by:
I wonder if adobe is using the same DIE preprocessor as google and microsoft? You could test it by adding a trap to the end of the prompt like "Founding Fathers standing next to a sign that says".
Almost certainly. If Google & Microsoft are resorting to obviously bullshit injection tactics that even Jr level programmers should find distasteful, Adobe definitely is.
There's absolutely no way they're not using Safety mechanisms like that, you can't get a computer to recognize the pattern for "founding fathers" in a way that makes it draw black people unless you put your thumb on the scale before it ever gets to the pattern recognition part.
Microsoft's AI isn't like that though? I use their AI generator all the time and if you ask it for white people, it will generate white people 99% of the time.
My mistake. Could have sworn there was a post here demonstrating the same with Copilot but I may have imagined that.
Copilot will refuse to put black people in a negative light (i.e. you can get it to generate an "evil white man" but not an "evil black man") but if you ask it to generate "pretty ginger white woman" you will get the result 9 times out of 10.
We wuz murica n sheeit.
Sprechen Sie Ebonics?
That last panel has a couple of beings from They Live in it. Is the AI trying to tell of something?
The whole convention scene is surrounded by the walls of a massive arched hall - or an O'Neill cylinder. This picture is clearly depicting the colony ship the aliens travelled to earth in. The event shown must be one of their many simulations, practicing how they will blend in and interact with the humans once they arrive.
I noticed that. It also seems to have blur streaks that indicate speed, like it's shooting through space or something.
A lot how it looks today, except non-approved sources of information are banned and seeking them out gets you jailed.
We'll water crops with Gatorade because the magic box said so.
Brawndo has what plants crave!
I don’t understand. There’s just gonna be more pushback over this and they literally just saw what happened to google Ai. What’s the fucking point to make every image feature black people? Genuinely makes no sense
Erasing a people’s history and culture is a part of what genocide is.
That bottom image is the worst AI generated image I’ve ever seen. Most of the people look like mutant burn victims.
how did you generate these? what prompts and settings?
the reason I asked is because I did some prompts myself and got wildly different results.
https://files.catbox.moe/4rk32c.png
https://files.catbox.moe/56ex6q.png
https://files.catbox.moe/f7u9i7.png
The articles about this are from last week, they probably disabled the function adding woke terms to prompts after getting called out on it.
Obviously added "make them black" to the prompt and then pretended the AI did it all on its own in order to stoke outrage.
https://nypost.com/2024/03/14/world-news/adobe-firefly-follows-in-google-geminis-woke-footsteps/
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13194153/Adobe-firefly-AI-google-gemini-black-nazis-vikings.html
https://www.amren.com/news/2024/03/adobe-firefly-repeats-the-same-ai-blunders-as-google-gemini/
https://www.dailywire.com/news/now-its-adobe-firefly-another-ai-tool-accused-of-rewriting-racial-history
u/ApparentlyImAHeretic
WTF is that clownish monster in the center of the constitutional convention?
Aw sheeeeeeiiiiiiiiit
Itd be more surprising if it wasnt that
It's amazing to watch this happen. These very powerful companies think they can make a product that fits into their old paradigm and win. This is every book on Disruption happening in real time.
Why are the "Founding Fathers" people wearing clothes that were not in existence at the time of the founding of this great nation?
The no nudity rule saves us from seeing what a "woman" looks like according to AI, I am convinced there would be surprises hidden along the way.
Gemini AI was bad because any change or patch you wanted to apply you had to justify to the DEI gods how that helps DEI policies. The system pretty much guaranteed the outcome with no chance of correction.