Pilpul, instead of defending the actual point, whether or not Jews are a biologically ethnic group that exerts disproportionate influence on their host nations, to the detriment of those host populations.
Instead you focus on word semantics because that’s how you muddle the point, jew.
Joe Biden's family is Catholic, would you consider him one?
Yes. Joe Biden is Catholic. Trad Caths may hate hearing this but Catholicism is every bit as cucked as Lefty Caths make it out to be. There is a reason the current Pope is such a cuck and it is because Catholicism is cucked.
As much as I hate defending the papists as a Lutherean, Catholicism was cucked by Vatican II, which is the culmination of a secret society plan to infiltrate it. The Permenant Instruction of the Alta Vendita was ordered published by two popes in the 19th century as a warning of the plot and can be found in its entirety in Grand Orient Freemasonry Unmasked. The most relevant chapters are XIV and XV.
Marxism is not just an economic theory. It is a political philosophy, and an integral part of that philosophy was the anti-Jewish writings penned by the two core political thinkers who gave rise to that philosophy, embodied by the generations who've followed in their footsteps: generations of ideologues calling themselves Marxists who will actively abandon all of the core principles they claim to adhere to in order to prop up Arabs and Muslims, just so they can take their side against Jews.
Calling leftist a Jewish plot or a Jewish philosophy is completely at odds with reality.
"Hanebrink declines to engage in counting how many Jews were communists. He identifies this question as misleading because to answer it one would have to use rigid ethnic categories when there were none. "
But also
"Hanebrink quotes the reaction of a Romanian gendarmerie inspector at the close of an investigation in 1941 that aimed to ascertain how many Jews had served the Soviets. It turned out that in one particular county, only three out of 128 local officials had been Jews."
So I was curious enough to click, and it turns out he apparently wrote an entire fucking book on dodging questions and double standards about when it is and isn't ok to use rigid ethnic categories.
For all your rants about how "the stormfags are coming!" you dig up more anti-semitic stuff than anyone.
Well if that link is evidence of what your idea of a fact is, I think the answer to that question is because you seem to choose which blatantly biased ideological shill pieces to believe based on whether they disagree with your favourite strawman or not.
The real world is more complicated than "Jew bad." I hope one day you get smart enough to actually put some legitimate effort into your analysis instead of lazily resorting to the lowest common denominator.
The political philosophy of Marx & Engels has nothing to do with the followers. Their weight is thrown mostly in economics (at least Carl's) so my post was centered on that.
To take it a bit farther let's just say " independence & self sufficiency" , do anyone has something against it? i guess no. This is the core idea behind Simon de Bolivar and the so called "Bolivarianism" yet Simon was the first to shit on it by becoming a tyrant. So yeah political & economic philosophies usually have nothing to do with their application even if the philosopher is behind policy.
Since you know so much about Marx i would say that Bakunin was right and Marx should be the one kicked out of the International. Even he was the man behind the whole project.
And because Marxism has long been separated from its' original vision, as the Frankfurt School's concept of Cultural Marxism has completely taken over the general Marxist movement. The Frankfurt School was ran by Jews.
"Karl Marx was born in 1818 in Trier, Prussia; he was the oldest surviving boy in a family of nine children. Both of his parents were Jewish, and descended from a long line of rabbis, but his father, a lawyer, converted to Lutheranism in 1816 due to contemporary laws barring Jews from higher society."
Because this place infested with stormcucks who hates facts.
Jews are not a monolith, that mentality is similar to SJWs thinking whites are a monolith. Marx hated Jews and Judaism. So much so he created and said many of the same things stormcucks parrot today.
Karl Marx was born in 1818 in Trier, Prussia; he was the oldest surviving boy in a family of nine children. Both of his parents were Jewish, and descended from a long line of rabbis, but his father, a lawyer, converted to Lutheranism in 1816 due to contemporary laws barring Jews from higher society.
Communist movements have always been led by the tribe . Look at Bolsheviks and founder of the German communist party etc. etc. Almost like the ideology comes from someone who was born to two rabbi families and had a Jewish mentality or something. And then there's Frankfurt School which created the main form of Marxism today. Frankfurt school was entirely Jewish.
Most of the work "credited" to the Frankfurt School was already in progress before it existed.
One I'm very aware of is the ridiculous accusation that they created feminism, which was actually created in the current radical form by the British upper class women of the WSPU.
"ridiculous" oh im sure JIDF. .
Frankfurt school created what is essentially cultural marxism and feminism is one of the biggest factors of that. Oh and Jews are a matriarchal culture. Which you still dont want to address.
Marx was not white, Frankfurt school was not white. Leaders of the bolsheviks was not whites, funders of CCP were not white. So if by white people you mean "fellow whites" then sure
I said "funders of CCP " you JIDF are so desperate to pretend you can't read huh? Also you are projecting. You are the SJW that constantly gets triggered by anyone saying anything about jews.
Because if you used that term instead of Marxism when describing how the left has changed society over the past century or two, you'd be accused of anti-semitism.
You're accused of it regardless, especially when you criticize the complete oxymoronic actions of the jewish leadership in the USA (open borders, no wall) vs the jewish leadership in Israel (closed borders, USA taxpayer funded wall).
By now it must be clear that the US economy is based on a theory of constant population growth, and with our "better halves" being in control, that isn't going to come naturally. Immigration is the logical choice to prop up the economy.
The way the Democrats use it is by choosing immigrants from places that have low average IQ. You can see the shift to Haitian migrants from Mexicans as the actions of the matriarchy turn Hispanics against it.
Because everybody loves simple solutions to complex problems.
If you can look around at all the chaos in the world, and blame it on one demographic, it's far easier than actually delving into the issues and trying to figure out a way to pull us all out of the abyss.
The backdrop of an economic collapse of course had nothing to do with people turning to degeneracy to fund their lives.
I've heard the bullshit a thousand times about the Weimar Republic, but everyone knows it was a failed state. They printed money to pay debts which exacerbated the global effect of the Wall Street Crash of 1929.
This destroyed the value of savings and forced people to perform sexual favors to eat.
You can see a warped modern version if you look at the OnlyThots after Covid.
Keep in mind that Marx's collaborator Engels was a gentile, something conveniently forgotten by anti-Semites. Marxism wouldn't have been possible without Engels.
Marx was a /pol/ poster of the 19th century, which is fitting because half of people on /pol/ are Russian Jews.
an excerpt of a letter Marx wrote to Friedrich Engels on July 30, 1862:
The Jewish nigger Lassalle who, I’m glad to say, is leaving at the end of this week, has happily lost another 5,000 talers in an ill-judged speculation. The chap would sooner throw money down the drain than lend it to a ‘friend,’ even though his interest and capital were guaranteed. … It is now quite plain to me—as the shape of his head and the way his hair grows also testify—that he is descended from the negroes who accompanied Moses’ flight from Egypt (unless his mother or paternal grandmother interbred with a nigger). Now, this blend of Jewishness and Germanness, on the one hand, and basic negroid stock, on the other, must inevitably give rise to a peculiar product. The fellow’s importunity is also niggerlike.
This letter, written in German, is translated and reproduced in Karl Marx, Frederick Engels, Collected Works (Moscow: Progress Publishers, 1985), pp. 388-391. It is important to note that Marx wrote the N-word in English as reproduced above; he occasionally wrote other foreign words in their original language (see the preface to the Collected Works, p. XXXVIII). The same translation appears on a Marxist website, the Marxists Internet Archive.
When he wrote the letter, Marx was angry with his democratic socialist “friend” Ferdinand Lassalle for refusing to lend him money. Lassalle was Jewish and, as far as we know, had no black ancestor.
He hated his parents, who happened to be Jewish. You can tell that’s what it’s all about because his father gave him money to go to school to become a lawyer, and his main complaint about the Jews was their “obsession with money”.
Every time I confront stormcucks over this they weasel out. Every time I tell them that their stupid arguments almost always comes from Marx or commies, they sperg out and goes on a denial screech.
Hilariously, if you do the same to their blue haired brothers, they sperg out and screech as well!
You do no such thing. You just embarrass yourself in thread after thread with stupid name calling.
You single handedly make half of the discussions on this board unreadable because it's just your delusion of grandeur playing itself out over and over again.
Because he comes from a family of Rabbis. Marx's father Heinrich, whose original name was Hirschel ha-Levi, was the son of a rabbi and the descendant of talmudic scholars for many generations.
Biden's family is Catholic, would you consider him one?
Half of Biden's cabinet is Jewish and he has a person he calls his rabbi. I don't care about Biden though, he's just a figurehead.
Judaism isn't just a religion, in order to be Jewish you must also be biologically Jewish. You can't simply convert to it.
LoL not entirely true. There's an ethnic core, but you can still convert to Judaism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conversion_to_Judaism
yeah dude let's talk about the 1% non-ethnic jews who converted and are irrelevant in any discussion
The point is it really isn't an incorrect statement.
Pilpul, instead of defending the actual point, whether or not Jews are a biologically ethnic group that exerts disproportionate influence on their host nations, to the detriment of those host populations.
Instead you focus on word semantics because that’s how you muddle the point, jew.
All his kids married jews and half his cabinet is jewish.
Yes. Joe Biden is Catholic. Trad Caths may hate hearing this but Catholicism is every bit as cucked as Lefty Caths make it out to be. There is a reason the current Pope is such a cuck and it is because Catholicism is cucked.
As much as I hate defending the papists as a Lutherean, Catholicism was cucked by Vatican II, which is the culmination of a secret society plan to infiltrate it. The Permenant Instruction of the Alta Vendita was ordered published by two popes in the 19th century as a warning of the plot and can be found in its entirety in Grand Orient Freemasonry Unmasked. The most relevant chapters are XIV and XV.
No. Any Pope worth his salt would have excommunicated Biden years ago.
Marx - a person
Marxism - an economic theory
Marxism is not just an economic theory. It is a political philosophy, and an integral part of that philosophy was the anti-Jewish writings penned by the two core political thinkers who gave rise to that philosophy, embodied by the generations who've followed in their footsteps: generations of ideologues calling themselves Marxists who will actively abandon all of the core principles they claim to adhere to in order to prop up Arabs and Muslims, just so they can take their side against Jews.
Calling leftist a Jewish plot or a Jewish philosophy is completely at odds with reality.
Explain the Bolsheviks? explain CCP funders? Explain Frankfurt School ? All almost entirely Jewish .
https://www.europenowjournal.org/2020/01/15/a-specter-haunting-europe-the-myth-of-judeo-bolshevism-by-paul-hanebrink/
But also
So I was curious enough to click, and it turns out he apparently wrote an entire fucking book on dodging questions and double standards about when it is and isn't ok to use rigid ethnic categories.
For all your rants about how "the stormfags are coming!" you dig up more anti-semitic stuff than anyone.
And yet, facts seem to disagree with ALL the claims stormcucks cook up. Why is that?
Well if that link is evidence of what your idea of a fact is, I think the answer to that question is because you seem to choose which blatantly biased ideological shill pieces to believe based on whether they disagree with your favourite strawman or not.
This reads a lot like projection that an SJW does when they are proven wrong. On that question, why do you choose to be an SJW?
You are hopelessly brainwashed. I'm sorry you don't see the real world. Maybe one day you'll wake up.
The real world is more complicated than "Jew bad." I hope one day you get smart enough to actually put some legitimate effort into your analysis instead of lazily resorting to the lowest common denominator.
A common denominator is... A common denominator.
The political philosophy of Marx & Engels has nothing to do with the followers. Their weight is thrown mostly in economics (at least Carl's) so my post was centered on that.
To take it a bit farther let's just say " independence & self sufficiency" , do anyone has something against it? i guess no. This is the core idea behind Simon de Bolivar and the so called "Bolivarianism" yet Simon was the first to shit on it by becoming a tyrant. So yeah political & economic philosophies usually have nothing to do with their application even if the philosopher is behind policy.
Since you know so much about Marx i would say that Bakunin was right and Marx should be the one kicked out of the International. Even he was the man behind the whole project.
Because Marx was a Jew, even if he hated Jews.
And because Marxism has long been separated from its' original vision, as the Frankfurt School's concept of Cultural Marxism has completely taken over the general Marxist movement. The Frankfurt School was ran by Jews.
He wasn't.
https://www.philosophersmag.com/opinion/30-karl-marx-s-radical-antisemitism
Self-loathing exists
Your argument is akin to saying Clayton Bigsby isn't black just because he is a white nationalist in his political belief
For that to happen, he would need to be Jewish. He wasn't.
"Karl Marx was born in 1818 in Trier, Prussia; he was the oldest surviving boy in a family of nine children. Both of his parents were Jewish, and descended from a long line of rabbis, but his father, a lawyer, converted to Lutheranism in 1816 due to contemporary laws barring Jews from higher society."
Thanks, ", converted to Lutheranism "
Did they also convert their ethnic identity?!? Their heritage and history?
The downvotes are hitting you hard for a reason - you are trying really hard to subvert and deceive, and no one is buying it!!
Because this place infested with stormcucks who hates facts.
Jews are not a monolith, that mentality is similar to SJWs thinking whites are a monolith. Marx hated Jews and Judaism. So much so he created and said many of the same things stormcucks parrot today.
Karl Marx was born in 1818 in Trier, Prussia; he was the oldest surviving boy in a family of nine children. Both of his parents were Jewish, and descended from a long line of rabbis, but his father, a lawyer, converted to Lutheranism in 1816 due to contemporary laws barring Jews from higher society.
Communist movements have always been led by the tribe . Look at Bolsheviks and founder of the German communist party etc. etc. Almost like the ideology comes from someone who was born to two rabbi families and had a Jewish mentality or something. And then there's Frankfurt School which created the main form of Marxism today. Frankfurt school was entirely Jewish.
Most of the work "credited" to the Frankfurt School was already in progress before it existed.
One I'm very aware of is the ridiculous accusation that they created feminism, which was actually created in the current radical form by the British upper class women of the WSPU.
"ridiculous" oh im sure JIDF. . Frankfurt school created what is essentially cultural marxism and feminism is one of the biggest factors of that. Oh and Jews are a matriarchal culture. Which you still dont want to address.
None of those people were even born when the WSPU was acting. It was a pre-WW1 feminist terrorism group.
Now are you going to admit you're wrong or screech your usual?
The fuck is a challah?
It is a very tasty bread that the moron above is jealous of.
Well, the only thing stormcucks invented was the abomination that is the Volkswagen Beetle.
https://www.europenowjournal.org/2020/01/15/a-specter-haunting-europe-the-myth-of-judeo-bolshevism-by-paul-hanebrink/
no amount of whining about "muh antisemitism" is going to change the facts of who created and who led these communist movements
White people?
Check the citation
Marx was not white, Frankfurt school was not white. Leaders of the bolsheviks was not whites, funders of CCP were not white. So if by white people you mean "fellow whites" then sure
No, the CCP is Chinese. Obviously.
i said "funders of CCP " can you not read?
You didn't read the citation. Do you enjoy being wrong?
Marx may have had Jewish ancestry(white), but he was Christia, "had converted formally to Christianity". Bolsheviks were whites, CCP were Asians.
Why are you an SJW?
And bolshevik leaders was majority jewish
Citation that I gave says otherwise
I said "funders of CCP " you JIDF are so desperate to pretend you can't read huh? Also you are projecting. You are the SJW that constantly gets triggered by anyone saying anything about jews.
[citation needed]
Why do people focus on Marxism when Marxism has been entirely supplanted in all its forms by Bolshevism?
Because if you used that term instead of Marxism when describing how the left has changed society over the past century or two, you'd be accused of anti-semitism.
You're accused of it regardless, especially when you criticize the complete oxymoronic actions of the jewish leadership in the USA (open borders, no wall) vs the jewish leadership in Israel (closed borders, USA taxpayer funded wall).
That's just hypocrisy, not oxymoronic.
Potato ... Potato.
Neither did Marx.
I...never said he did.
By now it must be clear that the US economy is based on a theory of constant population growth, and with our "better halves" being in control, that isn't going to come naturally. Immigration is the logical choice to prop up the economy.
The way the Democrats use it is by choosing immigrants from places that have low average IQ. You can see the shift to Haitian migrants from Mexicans as the actions of the matriarchy turn Hispanics against it.
There are a lot of Jews who do support Marxism. They're all idiots, but then, so is everyone who supports Marxism.
Because everybody loves simple solutions to complex problems.
If you can look around at all the chaos in the world, and blame it on one demographic, it's far easier than actually delving into the issues and trying to figure out a way to pull us all out of the abyss.
Weimar Republic 1920s
A hotbed of degeneracy, sin and debauchery
First transsexual surgery in the world
Jews owned the banks, the entertainment industry and the information media
And for absolutely no reason at all ...
The backdrop of an economic collapse of course had nothing to do with people turning to degeneracy to fund their lives.
I've heard the bullshit a thousand times about the Weimar Republic, but everyone knows it was a failed state. They printed money to pay debts which exacerbated the global effect of the Wall Street Crash of 1929.
This destroyed the value of savings and forced people to perform sexual favors to eat.
You can see a warped modern version if you look at the OnlyThots after Covid.
Do you worship communists?
Keep in mind that Marx's collaborator Engels was a gentile, something conveniently forgotten by anti-Semites. Marxism wouldn't have been possible without Engels.
It also wouldn't have been possible without Hegel, who wrote several theological condemnations of Judaism.
Post brought to you by the JIDF
Comment brought to you by the worshippers of a one-balled god.
?
Kek.
So hilarious how little do they know about their one balled god.
Marx was a /pol/ poster of the 19th century, which is fitting because half of people on /pol/ are Russian Jews.
He hated his parents, who happened to be Jewish. You can tell that’s what it’s all about because his father gave him money to go to school to become a lawyer, and his main complaint about the Jews was their “obsession with money”.
Because places like ours attract obnoxious brainlets who blame the jews for everything.
Jewish people literally take credit for most of this shit. Quoting them is a hate crime.
Are you retarded, or did you miss the point of the entire thing?
Every time I confront stormcucks over this they weasel out. Every time I tell them that their stupid arguments almost always comes from Marx or commies, they sperg out and goes on a denial screech.
Hilariously, if you do the same to their blue haired brothers, they sperg out and screech as well!
And yet, only one is right, and screech some more, because facts don't care about stormcucks feefees
You do no such thing. You just embarrass yourself in thread after thread with stupid name calling.
You single handedly make half of the discussions on this board unreadable because it's just your delusion of grandeur playing itself out over and over again.
Do I need to count the times Jews get blamed for nothing here, or being called JIDF or Jewish subverter?
Right, because of your confirmation bias this doesn't count, and I need to shut up and not fight back.
Inbred