7
Eltrion 7 points ago +7 / -0

No, Vivian was only trans in the Italian version. In English and German Vivian was a girl, and in all other versions, including Japanese, Vivian was a feminine looking boy, and the confusion other characters had was a source of humour.

2
Eltrion 2 points ago +2 / -0

With some further research, this line is from stg4_usu_121, and only exists in the switch version. So I guess they're putting this stuff in the Japanese version too. Concerning...

8
Eltrion 8 points ago +8 / -0

Yes, the trans Vivian thing seems to have two sources. 1)Leftist rumors fueled by what they want to be true, and 2) The Italian Translation, which was clearly an activist translation that took substantial liberties with the script. Notice how all the citations are trashy blog posts from gaming rags from the last five years, and the only references from the gamecube era are in reference to the Italian translation.

This whole thing is mostly based on people who don't speak Japanese telling each other with confidence that Vivian is super, for sure, definitely trans in the original script, and taking it as fact, and that Nintendo has censored their trans representation, rather than a Japanese style femboy of the sort you'd see in a cheesy anime.

18
Eltrion 18 points ago +18 / -0

Yes. Vivian is called a boy consistantly throughout the Japanese script. At no point is Vivian referred to as a girl without it being quickly corrected. Even Vivian does not claim to be a girl outside of the initial "Three Shadow Sisters" line.

This is a classic trap joke. The character is male, everyone knows that Vivian is male. But characters have to correct themselves because the character is so feminine that it messes with their intuition. To claim otherwise shows a lack of understanding of how these Japanese tropes work.

If there is another place in the script where Vivian claims to be a girl, please point it out, but as far as I can tell, this nonsense all hinges on the "Three Shadow Sisters" line, which isn't so much Vivian claiming to be a girl, but rather an effeminate boy acting effeminate as a setup for Beldum to explain that Vivian is a trap.

26
Eltrion 26 points ago +26 / -0

Don't trust Leftist controlled sources like Wikipedia. Go to the original script. In Japanese, French, and Spanish, the character was male, and his feminine appearance and demeanor was a joke.

5
Eltrion 5 points ago +5 / -0

Source on this? As far as I know the Japanese script is pretty consistent on Vivian being a boy. Does Vivian even claim to be a girl in the Japanese version outside of introducing the group as the "Three Shadow Sisters?"

11
Eltrion 11 points ago +11 / -0

For reference, in the original:

English, German: This character is a girl

Japanese, French, Spanish: This character is an Effeminate Boy, and it's played for laughs.

Italian: This character is Transgender.

17
Eltrion 17 points ago +17 / -0

I need to see an eng(old)/jp(old)/eng(new)/jp(new) comparison on this game as soon as possible.

2
Eltrion 2 points ago +2 / -0

XBOX also has the least incentive to tough it out. I expect the next XBOX (if there is one) will be a prebuilt PC running XBOX OS which will be a slightly tweaked version of Windows.

4
Eltrion 4 points ago +4 / -0

Seriously. At this point, if pirates began attacking boats in the English Channel, it would be a net positive for Britain.

10
Eltrion 10 points ago +10 / -0

Yes, at most he was the Japanese equivalent of that English bugler. More likely he was entirely fictional, or actually just Okinawan.

9
Eltrion 9 points ago +9 / -0

The whole man/bear thing seems perfectly engineered to make men and women hate each other.

I don't know for what purpose, but it certainly seems effective.

4
Eltrion 4 points ago +4 / -0

Yeah, if Nintendo wanted to make a collectathon, there's no reason they wouldn't stick DK, Yoshi, or Wario in there.

If there's one thing Nintendo isn't short on, it's IP.

5
Eltrion 5 points ago +5 / -0

Aka "Why you don't let Emma Watson sing" the Movie.

There wasn't nearly enough criticism of that movie. Wasn't the Aladdin one after that? Somehow that one did alright despite how terrible it looked.

11
Eltrion 11 points ago +11 / -0

Nah, what they do have, is 3d models from the last movie that they invested a lot of time in.

What they don't have, is people talented enough to make 2d animation of high enough quality that it won't be compared with Hunchback of Notre dame 2.

16
Eltrion 16 points ago +16 / -0

And unfortunately, you two have now just discussed the politics and power dynamics at a level deeper than anything Disney is capable of anymore. We'll get girlboss Shenzi and absolutely none of this.

5
Eltrion 5 points ago +5 / -0

Eh, they have their pros and cons.

At the end of the day, having a deck of 2000 characters to memorize isn't really that much when you consider how difficult learning a language is, and it gives you a really straightforward framework that gives you a ton of clues later in your learning.

On the other hand there are a ton that look way to similar to each other.

I still stand by my conclusion that Japanese isn't that much harder than other non-romance languages, it's just front loaded.

27
Eltrion 27 points ago +27 / -0

I really have to respect the way he set his goal of 2 billion dollars, got the two billion dollars, and then rode into the sunset to a life of freedom and relaxation instead of getting caught on the greed treadmill like so many of the upper class do.

7
Eltrion 7 points ago +7 / -0

Learn Japanese, not to play your favorite games in their original format, but to once again witness the artistry of language once English has been subsumed into nothing but an unintelligible hodge podge of political buzzwords, ebonics, and zoomer slang.

4
Eltrion 4 points ago +4 / -0

Tits that fake are normally disappointing when they are fully bare. Implants are often intended to make cleavage look nice, even at the expense of the appearance of the rest of the breast.

2
Eltrion 2 points ago +2 / -0

It's a favorite tactic of leftists.

Something bad happens and someone they dislike is in power -> "clearly the administration could have fixed this instantly, but they didn't because they're evil"

Something bad happens and someone they like is in power -> "the current administration has only been in power for 3 years, that's not enough time to make any real change! This is clearly the previous administrations fault!"

7
Eltrion 7 points ago +7 / -0

Yeah isn't the reveal of hooktails gender part of a "darling baby sister" joke during the gloomtail fight?

15
Eltrion 15 points ago +15 / -0

And here we see, exemplified by perhaps the game with the best writing a Mario game has ever had, why language as an art is dying under the crushing weight of leftist tyranny.

view more: ‹ Prev Next ›