IT ... IT'S PERFECT! 😭
(media.scored.co)
Comments (22)
sorted by:
The new Ghost in the Shell absolutely nails it!
The art style, color palette, music, and sound design are exactly what they needed to be, and the characters and dialogue feel truer to the spirit of the original manga than the franchise has in years. Visually, its depiction of ghosts, cyberbrains, and hacking is creative and kinetic. Rather than stopping to explain the technology, it simply shows you how it's used and trusts you to keep up.
The storytelling is, in many ways, an improvement over Production I.G.'s Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex. Rather than relying on lengthy, clunky exposition dumps, it conveys information organically through natural conversations between characters. Unlike like in SAC, the audience isn't treated like an invisible observer to be lectured; instead, the world reveals itself naturally as the story unfolds.
The action is another standout. It's smart, purposeful, and tightly paced. There's a world of difference between the indulgent spectacle of Transformers and the thoughtful, consequential action of Mission: Impossible - Fallout, and this series firmly belongs in the latter camp. Every action sequence serves the story instead of merely filling screen time. In fact, despite running a full 22 minutes, the premiere ends just as it feels like it's getting started -- it really holds your attention like that. It doesn't waste a single minute.
The premiere also avoids turning into a philosophical symposium. Instead, it gives you just enough context and world-building to make the stakes meaningful without sacrificing momentum. The deeper themes are still there, but they're woven into the narrative in a way that rewards you for paying attention instead of stopping the story to explain itself.
Music is an essential part of the show and Science SARU uses it brilliantly. The soundtrack moves between the Major's playful sass, moments of genuine drama, and bursts of kinetic action without ever feeling out of place. At times, it even evokes shades of Cowboy Bebop, blending pop, jazz, and orchestral influences in a way that's unmistakably Japanese.
Overall, it's the closest adaptation to the original manga while still forging its own identity. It honors the 1995 film with subtle visual cues and stylistic nods, yet presents everything through a fresh, youthful lens that feels vibrant, accessible, and exciting for a new generation.
I love it. I absolutely love it. 😍
If the rest of the series maintains this level of quality, it'll stand among the very finest Ghost in the Shell adaptations ever made. It's not "better" than Production I.G.'s interpretation; it's just refreshingly different. If Production I.G.'s Ghost in the Shell is vanilla ice cream with Nutella, Science SARU's version is strawberry with gummy bears. One's a little more mature, the other a little more playful, but I love them both.
I see a lot of negations, as well as predictable sentence structure. Did you write this with AI?
No, why would I need to? I wrote it myself after seeing the episode an hour ago.
Go see it yourself!
Nah, you definitely used AI here.
Show me on the doll where my review hurt you and your four alts. 🙄
Right here
He didn't ask if you needed to, he asked if you did
And I said, "no."
But don't worry, if you go back to school, you too can learn how to form sentences and use proper punctuation.
This will be the whole internet in five years; anyone who can write a paragraph or use punctuation correctly will be accused of being AI.
To be fair, OP's use of "--" is a VERY common shibboleth of AI usage. Normal people don't use double-hyphens much at all, even internet-normal people, while AI absolutely LOVES them for some reason.
It's like... If someone came out wearing a swastica and declaring that Jews were causing problems in their homelands, your first thought would be "nazi", not "tribal indian who still uses the swastica in their religious iconography". The latter is perfectly possible, as is someone who enjoys using "--" instead of an AI doing it, it's just not the first thought that comes to mind. Or the second.
As someone who spent a lot of time doing technical writing, the death of the emdash pains me.
The paragraph like here doesn't sound personal. I don't know your writing style so I'm just guessing it but I'm so sorry but it's really like ai speech especially "There's a world of difference between the indulgent spectacle of Transformers and the thoughtful, consequential action of Mission: Impossible – Fallout, and this series firmly belongs in the latter camp. Every action sequence serves the story instead of merely filling screen time." It's too proper, too corporate and I generally am an advocate of AI.
Nobody uses word symposium in the casual forums. Once again a lot of words here doesn't have that personal touch. It sounds really like corporate speak.
There's an emdash at first and then there's two hyphens masquerading as an emdash.
There is no emdash, but wouldn't that inconsistency prove it isn't written by AI?
Honestly, at this point I'm convinced you fucking parasites just want to drain my good mood.
Without doxxing myself too much, I did write professional reviews in college. My apologies for having such an eclectic verbal pallet, which I understand that you've deemed impersonal and inappropriate for such a pedestrian forum where we lament jewish maleficence and our prejudice towards pajeets. That said, the exposition dumps between characters in GitS really do come across like symposiums. Anyhow ...
Ahem. Sorry I make Grug think big word too much, m'kay? 🙄
Werd, nigga. deadass. These Jap niggas be hopp'n, you know? 😎
It just read strangely, is all. I’ll check it out.
I'm glad to see them finally doing something with Masamune Shirow's aesthetic again. Not that the movie and SAC didn't have their own positives but we hadn't seen his art style animated since when? The Tank Police OVAs?
Hopefully they do it justice.
I like the faces they make.
The character expressions are great. This series really is much more playful and youthful than anything before it, but still respectful of the material. It walks a perfect line. Netflix's SAC_2045 was a stiff, stale impersonation of Production I.G.'s GitS that everyone knew to avoid just from the trailer. Honestly, most fans do well to pretend that it never happened. This new series is a breath of fresh air!