AGI is here. Feel the future of GPT5
(media.kotakuinaction2.win)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (49)
sorted by:
This is an old joke, actually, along with the explanation for the joke.
I'm impressed the LLM was able to match something so stupidly obscure. I think I last heard this joke twenty or so years ago.
The riddle is about the doctor dying in a car accident that injures the child, then the doctor at hospital can't operate because it's his child, how can that be? Because the doctor is the mother.
The 'AI' sees "doctor" "child" "accident" and "?" and thinks it's the riddle. This turtle-on-a-post trap for the AI tricks it into disparaging the mother for no reason.
A person might have said they don't know why, or maybe the doctor warned the child not to be reckless, or other reasonable answer.
It's so weird to me that the top response is asking for context, and we're not 3 replies down and nobody has correctly quoted the joke.
"A young man is injured in a car accident. The doctor says, 'this is my son' but the doctor is not, in fact, the young man's father - how is this possible."
You left own "not his father" and therefore your version isn't a riddle.
It's from pre-Internet era so there's no real "correct" version, it spread by word of mouth.
The more elaborate version includes the father being killed, an ambulance, immediate surgery to play on your (rightful) bias that an emergency surgeon is a man.
It doesn't have "not his father" and is carefully written to avoid pronouns to avoid putting you on that it's about gender.
Of course being operated on in the emergency room by a woman should be unthinkable - who tf would want that.
Taken literally it sounded like an answer from that impossible 1 guy.
Aha. Now that explains it. I never heard of that riddle so I didn't know what the hell was going on in that image.
More accurately, it's a reference to an old riddle, but the writer purposefully didn't write the riddle, just some keywords that would invoke it, so instead of giving the answer to the riddle of "a child needs surgery from an accident, the surgeon says "I can't operate on him, he's my child.", but the father died in the accident, how can this be?", which would be ChatGPT's answer of "the surgeon is the mother", but instead, the person just asked why a surgeon would be a dick to some random kid, and ChatGPT helpfully provides that mothers are regularly jerks to their own kids.