This is just an observation. YMMV, of course. But I've noticed this with increasing frequency in recent years...
It's not necessarily a "new" thing. Lying certainly isn't new. But I imagine there must have been a time when, hypothetically, you could make plans with someone, or discuss something, and they would damn well hold to it/keep their word...
Like, in my observation, this happens all the damn time: people flake, people change their mind at the last minute, people ghost (and I do it, too), people, worst of all, change plans, or change their mind, and don't even tell you...
I'm not talking just with women, either. My male "friends" do this. My family does this. Constantly. Randoms I meet, and plan to meet up with later, do this too. And sure, I'm a common factor, but I see this happening more generally, to all manner of people I know, too.
I really, really wish that we "as a society" hadn't normalised this... "Flaky", noncommittal, "my needs come first, always" bullshit...
I really, really do.
If there's a culture where keeping your word and actually committing is still the default, I look forward to one day finding it. Because I am yet to really... Ever experience that. And I've travelled fairly widely and met a lot of people.
Despite what schools teach nowadays, the US was founded on Christianity, and English society likewise was grounded on the Bible for hundreds of years. One core tenant was the teaching of Jesus, "let your yes be yes and your no be no," and this reflected throughout society.
Now, even the average church-goer isn't really God fearing in how they live their life, and the unchurched certainly aren't. Instead of "love your neighbor as yourself," self love is taught, to put one's emotions and desires above all else.
As a result, society has become filled with self centered liars and flakes, who make every decision first and foremost based on their own desires.
What you're describing is American degradation from a formerly high trust society into a low trust one.
Not even in America, but yes.
I honestly can’t say whether it is worse or better here, in that regard (what I saw and have experienced of the US was worse, but it wouldn’t be fair to judge a whole society based on that)… But also yes.
This seems to be fairly universal, in Western “developed” countries, tbh…
The West as a whole is suffering from the same infection.
Any country infected with third worlders will show the same symptoms. It's the core principle of nationalism. The nation is the people.
Flood a nation with third world trash, and society starts to decay.
Honestly [Im going to hell for this, but], the, uhh, “third world trash”, or at least many of the ones that cause the problems..?
Yeah, their ancestors (some of. Very few full-blood left!) we’re here even before Whitey… As was the dysfunction.
Which… Makes it even harder to deal with, lol.
But also what you said. Sudanese + Chinese + Lebanese + Vietnamese + Subcontinentals + Aboriginals + Pacific Islanders, all of whom refuse to integrate or assimilate..?
Yeah, it’s a recipe for disaster, lol…
It's strange how the one redeemable thing that is so pushed within the programming of modern society, the power of friendship, family, and generally the power of keeping your word is seen more as a negligiable guideline or something that is so unimportant that it comes second to an almost ubiquitous urge to just lie, no matter how important your word was to the person you gave it to.
At times it seems like we don't even speak a common language, we communicate with a surface level facade with confused, idiosyncratic babble underneath - connect at enough points of the molecule and you might hold together briefly, but the factor of cohesion through collective values just isn't in the pudding. Cohesion through manipulation and emotional or hierarchal blackmail seems to be much more successful.
I think that the main ingredient that is missing is the concept of self, the deeper kind. The self-concept is lacking in that we don't abstract these things as a part of ourselves anymore where we ought to and the unseen part that promulgates lies is a much more important faculty than the one that tells the truth. We value our word superficially because we live in a very superficial world, and are not equipped to think of our ability to keep our word as an extension of our character - and whenever you do, you are seen as autistic or get taken advantage of.
I think it is noble to atleast try and think of it as your own arm or leg, but that is just lost on most. How can anyone preach self-love if they let such a thing rot?
Good post. Knowledge of and love of self is an important building block in everything. It's a complex and difficult process, but in many ways you can boil it down to 'pride', an often maligned value. That is to say, pride as a concept of self-belief, not the kind of pride that you adopt as a surface level set of behaviours to cover deep insecurity. The trust that's lacking in society is a reflection of how many people have no real pride in themselves, since how can you expect anyone to trust you if you don't trust yourself? And what value can there be in obtaining other people's trust at that stage, except as a means of manipulating them?
Think of the word 'demoralisation' as Bezmenov used it. The most frequent usage of it in everyday society tends to refer to people's morale, their spirit, their courage. Someone with no courage has no trust in himself or other people to withstand negative outcomes. No pride, no trust. But such a person becomes 'demoralised' in an extra sense: they get divorced from any concept of moral values - because they lose all firm foundation of self, upon which to ground any of their ideals.
Being bereft of self-belief in this way, it really does seem like we've cultivated a generation or several generations of people who perform the surface level functions of real human behaviour but only in a spiritless, scared, shortsighted and treacherous way. From a deeper moral analysis, they seem hollow and they make for a brittle and seemingly soulless society.
Western culture has become soft and evasive of consequence over the past 60 years. There's a deficit of purpose and causal reasoning that's a primary factor in obnoxious behaviors being normalized. Adopt a constant mindset of your time being valuable, try to gauge if someone actually interested in a plan upfront, and appropriately scold them if they still want to do shit after flaking.
Yeah. Agreed. It’s just very frustrating coming from a family where this is, and was, always “normal”…
I had to teach myself that it wasn’t…
I can’t tell you how many times I was left waiting somewhere, after school, because my parents changed their plans and didn’t bother telling me in advance (as an example. “Conveniently” they lived an hour away)…
Dunno how I came to realise this wasn’t “normal”, actually…
My cousins still haven’t, lol, and we’re pretty much all adults, so…
It’s an odd thing.
I had a “best friend” who used to take advantage of me all the time, from around 17 - 21…
I knew something was “off”, but I had been so… Accustomed to that as being “the norm” that I just put up with it for years…
Took me moving interstate to realise that the relationship was almost entirely one way, lol…
Amen to breaking free of behavioral programming in spite of social pressure. I'm not gonna pretend to be an easily likable extrovert, but I've found investing in not being a push-over, with some ethical deception (personal motivation is filtering out literal-minded aspies and normies alike) pays off in the long run.
A consequence of overpopulation and social media is the devaluation of individual relationships.
I tried to explain that so much to people in 2020 and most never got it. They just couldn't get why I was not okay just being expected to sit around by myself and do nothing with no end in sight. I mean I've never been a social butterfly or anything but I learned really quick that with nothing to work towards personally and no personal interaction, I was basically already dead. Breathing and eating is not living.
Part of it is that a lot of people primarily interact with other people over screens now and it's much easier to act wrong when you have that layer of abstraction in the way.
As someone that hates breaking their own word this exact problem keeps me from a lot of social interactions.
As my health is quite frankly abysmal (nothing serious just highly inconvenient) I am very much hesitant to promise to do things yet it seems like more and more people just want that promise even of you don't keep it.
Oh well I'll stick to my principals either way, to the best of my ability at least.
One of the foundation aspects of western civilisation was that you meant what you said. Eroded away.
Honor, integrity, self-sacrifice, accountability and consequences are all lost concepts in the new world. Hedonism, self-love and self-gratification are the new moral virtues of the new religion.
It used to be that calling someone a liar was an insult worthy of a duel to the death. This is because your word meant something. Nowadays words are cheap and nobody bats an eye to slander and insult others without any justification or reason behind it.
Words were more scarce and more valuable, and the insights of people with experience or insight were greatly valued. Nowadays everyone feels entitled to have their opinions heard, and people feel encouraged or even obligated to have strong opinions about everything whether their opinions are worth anything or not.
Morality was objective under Christianity, then it became relative to tear down Christianity, and now it's purely utilitarian, specifically in respect to the political power of the high priests of the new religion. Morality, meaning, language... everything now serves the new religion. It's truly dystopian.
This is the method of discourse now. No honor, no integrity and no truth. Even in seemly innocuous everyday interactions.
And here I thought this avoidance of common decency was strictly a California thing.
I believe the anonymity of online communication . . . what we're doing here, now, lends itself to the sort of anti-social rudeness you refer to.
But then I can make a distinction between typed conversations and conversations in real life and the social customs involved, so I always assumed others can, but maybe it's also a generational problem.
My experiences of this may actually be fairly uniquely awful, unfortunately…
One of the worst things that I’ve had happen three times with different groups I was “friendly” with (for want of a more descriptive term) was where I proposed an idea for an activity or place we could go, we all agreed we should go together, only for them to go silent on it, and me to find out, some weeks later, that they had gone without me, and hadn’t even bothered to tell me (small groups, here, so I guess it was exclusion of sorts, but not purely being “left out”, if that makes sense)…
That particular “back stab” was cold enough to be friendship-ending, to be quite honest… Especially when they then get shitty when you call them out on it, lol…
Totally not cool. Even I, at the time, could see that…
I made that distinction too (or I try to), but yeah, I notice more and more that other people either do not or cannot…
And yeah, different continent, same problem.
Commit to something in person; weasel out of it later via text. That seems to be “the new norm”, in my experience…
And then you ask for an explanation as to why, and they just get all shitty…
I really hate that.
Others make good points. I'll add:
One of the many poisons of liberalism is treating the individual as the fundamental unit of society. This is wrong. The fundamental unit is the family (and family means at least 3 generations, not just parents + children).
With the individual subsumed socially to family and everything subsumed spiritually to Christ, suddenly the individual doesn't exist in a void. Duties and responsibilities, with harsh, if implied, consequences for failure, now constrain the courses of action available to an individual. Flaking wouldn't even occur to most in this world.
One of the other many benefits of this arrangement is that you no longer have to "find yourself." You can start your life right away: elder sons continue the family business, younger sons explore, daughters get married.
That world, or that dynamic, really no longer exists, in much of “mainstream” Western society, unfortunately…
Notably, it does in tightly knit immigrant communities, and it really, really does in Muslim/Middle Eastern ones…
Not so much in our “post-racial” multiculti “melting pot” Western societies, though… Unfortunately…
I had the same experience growing up, same learned behavior, same attitude as a result now…
Ain’t that interesting?
Literally exactly the same, dude.
Though I’m still learning to not be late to places/things, frankly. 😕
It’s definitely a learned habit, though…
Again, my cousins do this, too…
Clearly this shit runs in families. Unfortunately, lol…
Sometimes people are afraid to disappoint, and don't recognize, acknowledge, or really take into account their own limitations. Time management, focus and attention, self discipline, etc etc.
I think it's especially more common with just how increasingly time consuming it is to try and get just about any seemingly simple task done, especially with how finnicky and unreliable technology can be.
There's also so much more we want to do, get done, experience, and achieve, because there's so much more at our finger tips. And yet we still have just as little time as we've had for hundreds of years. More in some regards, but still a rather finite lifespan and a limited supply of energy and focus.
Might just be me projecting though. But that's something I've been feeling for a while now.
Interesting… I’ve said before that I don’t mind so much when people give me, let’s say, tenuous plans (like a “maybe”), and then pull out…
What I hate is when someone commits (“Oh yeah, definitely let’s do that!”), and then a) pulls out at the last minute, or b) changes their mind and doesn’t bother telling me…
That’s just rude and inconsiderate. I understand that time is finite, but this, this situation as I describe it, has resulted in so much wasted time and money on my part that I hardly even bother anymore, unfortunately…
I’m very, very jaded to people continuously doing this…