29 () posted 2 years ago by ThatsAlright 2 years ago by ThatsAlright +30 / -1 34 comments share 34 comments share save hide report block hide replies
Ok, let's turn this around to something we're concerned about.
What if you saw children being abused and stayed silent about it?
I would question the situation. Context always matters, despite what the Scottish courts say.
What is the context for the child's injury? What is the context for the negative statement about Judaism?
There are effectively zero baseline situations (that is, ones where context is not yet established) where no context is needed to make a decision.
Well, a child being raped in the street would warrant breaking the silence. But there is a universe of difference between child rape and some guy acting like a fool.