Do It For Her
(twitter.com)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (114)
sorted by:
In many respects it is. I did certainly imply it’s subjectivity when a user remarked elsewhere in the thread seal canvases v children scribbling on walls. To the hypothetical person, they don’t see the latter as art. I, personally, would, because art is inherently expression through a medium. Granted, to different degrees, I don’t find them equal art, but art nonetheless.
I don’t think, in the context of the parent thread, that AI slop is at all in line at all with art through activism/expression. It’s lines fed into a machine, that the user did not make, and the machine pores over data that the user did not log, and uses existing art that the user did not create, and outputs a video based on prompts that the user barely lifted a finger for.
It’s not expression. It’s data output.
What I just did in respect to the comment you replied to was ask a question to a different user, so I don’t really understand the context of your question.
Despite your use of the qualifier "personally," you just gave an objective definition. Your qualifier only applies to your application of that definition.
Data output is a form of expression. I'm not telling you that AI art is amazing or equally meritorious, but in many cases it is a form of basic art.
What is being expressed by the user? There is no emotion behind the prompt, no apparent goal, no motive. Simple request and output.
There is no expression.
By your strange definition, driving is not travel because somebody else built your car.
...lol what?
We're talking about art, not travel. Those aren't the same things. I don't even understand how you get to that line of thinking. I can't begin to find any connection between how a person making art is in any way related to a person driving a car to get from A to B.
There's no transitive property required in defining art vs defining travel. They are two very different things.
You are aware that you essentially just told me "but I did eat breakfast", right?
You're making huge leaps in connections my guy. How are you tying this in? We weren't talking about hypotheticals.
My stance on art is going to be different than my stance on travel because they're two different things. This shouldn't be that complicated.