This is a member of the Knesset in Israel. Somehow I missed the picture caption and thought it was a Jewish-French member of parliament in France. Regardless of her opinion, foreign legislators need to STFU about what happens in other countries.
Regardless of her opinion, foreign legislators need to STFU about what happens in other countries.
Normally, I'd agree but it's her grandmother. If one of my family members got attacked in an ostensibly Western country by some piece of garbage who was there because of a government refuses to deal with them, I'd be enraged too.
Her location and occupation don't really have bearing on this being a reasonable thing to be mad about. The other 99.999999% of the time foreign legislators run their mouths, I agree.
Her location and occupation have everything to do with it. Or have you not seen what Israel plans on doing with the displaced palestinians (assuming they don't just kill them all?)
The assertion was she's not entitled to comment on her grandmother being beaten specifically because she's a legislator in a different country.
If you want to talk about Israel's contributions to creating that problem in Europe in the first place, have at it. That's not what either of us were talking about.
We were speaking about her right to comment about her right to comment about domestic policy in a foreign country.
/u/Assassin47 asserted that she didn't have a right to comment because no politician has a right to comment about domestic policy in a foreign country. You asserted that in this case the general rule doesn't apply because it's her grandmother. I asserted that you are incorrect because she is part of a government that supports policies (that she presumably agrees with) that caused the situation she's complaining about.
If you read the article (and the opinion piece it quotes) she says the following:
My appeal to the people of France is unequivocal: defend diversity, protect minorities and be firm against’ intolerance. The future of your nation depends on your ability to maintain these values. If France fails to protect its Jewish citizens, it will inevitably fail to protect its own identity and integrity.
I am going to urge my grandmother to join us in Israel, a country she should have come to for a long time. But let this serve as a’ warning: when the Jews are gone, the native French will be next to have to leave or submit.
She doesn't believe France should be expelling foreigners with incompatible ideologies. She believes they should keep taking the worlds castoffs. She doesn't talk about making the muslims "leave or submit", no, it's the French that will have to do that.
This is a member of the Knesset in Israel. Somehow I missed the picture caption and thought it was a Jewish-French member of parliament in France. Regardless of her opinion, foreign legislators need to STFU about what happens in other countries.
Normally, I'd agree but it's her grandmother. If one of my family members got attacked in an ostensibly Western country by some piece of garbage who was there because of a government refuses to deal with them, I'd be enraged too.
Her location and occupation don't really have bearing on this being a reasonable thing to be mad about. The other 99.999999% of the time foreign legislators run their mouths, I agree.
Her location and occupation have everything to do with it. Or have you not seen what Israel plans on doing with the displaced palestinians (assuming they don't just kill them all?)
The assertion was she's not entitled to comment on her grandmother being beaten specifically because she's a legislator in a different country.
If you want to talk about Israel's contributions to creating that problem in Europe in the first place, have at it. That's not what either of us were talking about.
We were speaking about her right to comment about her right to comment about domestic policy in a foreign country.
/u/Assassin47 asserted that she didn't have a right to comment because no politician has a right to comment about domestic policy in a foreign country. You asserted that in this case the general rule doesn't apply because it's her grandmother. I asserted that you are incorrect because she is part of a government that supports policies (that she presumably agrees with) that caused the situation she's complaining about.
If you read the article (and the opinion piece it quotes) she says the following:
She doesn't believe France should be expelling foreigners with incompatible ideologies. She believes they should keep taking the worlds castoffs. She doesn't talk about making the muslims "leave or submit", no, it's the French that will have to do that.
This kike can get out and stay out.
That's fair, I forgot that part while writing. Also good of her to highlight Islamists instead of the old White Supremes chestnut.