I tend to think most dubs arent that bad, but will also admit that I am in the minority.
Also, I dont think saying "dub bad" helps here, because I have seen more than a few times where they changed the subtitle version. And when people pointed out that issue, some of these ass-munch little shits said "Guess you should learn Japanese if you dont like it then, Chud."
I am just so shocked the Japanese are kicking these people to the curb and saying "Nah, we are going to have bots do it because it is better than the gaijin doing it."
The problem with dubs is there's a HUGE discrepancy in quality compared to Japanese VAs.
Put this way, this is god tier voice work, this is great and this is above average. The better actress in the last one for the blonde chick is multilingual and VAs the same character in the original Japanese.
It shouldn't feel like a standout when an English VA puts some passion behind their lines meanwhile in the original versions you sometimes swear that the VAs are suffering traumatic experiences for their parts (remembers Goblin Slayer).
I agree subs can be just as bad at times but sometimes they seem to get some digs in to, think it was In another world with my smartphone that had a line saying she'd rather have a closeted pervert than a feminist for a master because the former can control themselves.
I feel like there is a growing resentment of foreigners messing with their culture in Japan, they can identify the ones that truly love their culture and they're happy with them (I notice YouTubers like Chris Broad get a pass easily) but that idiot they have locked up is showing they're done with the rest now, regardless of the US forcing the legislature to change laws.
Dont get me wrong, I am absolutely agreeing that there is a huge discrepancy. I am probably have just been lucky in that most I have listened to for dubs have actually been at least good. There are plenty I still watch sub over dub (like you said, Goblin Slayer is much better in Japanese). It is just that on average I will take dub over sub because I would rather be watching what is going on instead of trying to read the subtitles. Sometimes stuff didnt get a dub, or sometimes the dub is an absolute trainwreck, and I will watch subs then. But if there seems to be no real difference in quality to me (like Rising of the Shield Hero), then I will take dub.
Just for my own example, Kayuga-sama I think is better as dub than sub, but a lot of the changes in tone and extra lines on the part of the narrator were changes signed off on by the studio so it is still staying true to the vision (and the over the top nature fits the anime more, IMO).
I feel like there is a growing resentment of foreigners messing with their culture in Japan,
Fully agree on this one though. I know that most Japanese are still OK with Americans and still love it, as well as loving America itself (I recently saw some clips of a few Japanese Hololive Vtubers who went to vacation in LA and said how they loved it there and liked how open and friendly Americans were, even if they thought it seemed kind of dangerous at night). But that is because most Americans like Japan for being Japan. Ironically, it is the "We are totally not racist" Woke Twitter Freaks who are the most anti-Japanese. But that tracks since they are anti-everything that doesnt live up to their California Bay Area sensibilities.
I tend to think most dubs arent that bad, but will also admit that I am in the minority.
Also, I dont think saying "dub bad" helps here, because I have seen more than a few times where they changed the subtitle version. And when people pointed out that issue, some of these ass-munch little shits said "Guess you should learn Japanese if you dont like it then, Chud."
I am just so shocked the Japanese are kicking these people to the curb and saying "Nah, we are going to have bots do it because it is better than the gaijin doing it."
The problem with dubs is there's a HUGE discrepancy in quality compared to Japanese VAs.
Put this way, this is god tier voice work, this is great and this is above average. The better actress in the last one for the blonde chick is multilingual and VAs the same character in the original Japanese.
It shouldn't feel like a standout when an English VA puts some passion behind their lines meanwhile in the original versions you sometimes swear that the VAs are suffering traumatic experiences for their parts (remembers Goblin Slayer).
I agree subs can be just as bad at times but sometimes they seem to get some digs in to, think it was In another world with my smartphone that had a line saying she'd rather have a closeted pervert than a feminist for a master because the former can control themselves.
I feel like there is a growing resentment of foreigners messing with their culture in Japan, they can identify the ones that truly love their culture and they're happy with them (I notice YouTubers like Chris Broad get a pass easily) but that idiot they have locked up is showing they're done with the rest now, regardless of the US forcing the legislature to change laws.
Dont get me wrong, I am absolutely agreeing that there is a huge discrepancy. I am probably have just been lucky in that most I have listened to for dubs have actually been at least good. There are plenty I still watch sub over dub (like you said, Goblin Slayer is much better in Japanese). It is just that on average I will take dub over sub because I would rather be watching what is going on instead of trying to read the subtitles. Sometimes stuff didnt get a dub, or sometimes the dub is an absolute trainwreck, and I will watch subs then. But if there seems to be no real difference in quality to me (like Rising of the Shield Hero), then I will take dub.
Just for my own example, Kayuga-sama I think is better as dub than sub, but a lot of the changes in tone and extra lines on the part of the narrator were changes signed off on by the studio so it is still staying true to the vision (and the over the top nature fits the anime more, IMO).
Fully agree on this one though. I know that most Japanese are still OK with Americans and still love it, as well as loving America itself (I recently saw some clips of a few Japanese Hololive Vtubers who went to vacation in LA and said how they loved it there and liked how open and friendly Americans were, even if they thought it seemed kind of dangerous at night). But that is because most Americans like Japan for being Japan. Ironically, it is the "We are totally not racist" Woke Twitter Freaks who are the most anti-Japanese. But that tracks since they are anti-everything that doesnt live up to their California Bay Area sensibilities.
Slight fact that think they were in a relationship at the time and he had to walk out of the booth after this scene as her screaming was TOO real.