Win / KotakuInAction2
KotakuInAction2
Communities Topics Log In Sign Up
Sign In
Hot
All Posts
Settings
All
Profile
Saved
Upvoted
Hidden
Messages

Your Communities

General
AskWin
Funny
Technology
Animals
Sports
Gaming
DIY
Health
Positive
Privacy
News
Changelogs

More Communities

frenworld
OhTwitter
MillionDollarExtreme
NoNewNormal
Ladies
Conspiracies
GreatAwakening
IP2Always
GameDev
ParallelSociety
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Content Policy
DEFAULT COMMUNITIES • All General AskWin Funny Technology Animals Sports Gaming DIY Health Positive Privacy
KotakuInAction2 The Official Gamergate Forum
hot new rising top

Sign In or Create an Account

33
posted 3 years ago by KevO4444 3 years ago by KevO4444 +33 / -0
33 comments share
33 comments share save hide report block hide replies
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (33)
sorted by:
▲ 6 ▼
– -Fender- 6 points 3 years ago +6 / -0

The three first Peter Jackson movies are fantastic, and a clear recommendation for everyone. You should definitely watch those. There are a few clear differences, like Arwen being the one to rescue Frodo on Wintertop instead of Glorfindel, and Tom Bombadil and the Scouring of the Shire being cut out entirely, but it's still definitely a clear homage to the books and extremely well-made movies.

For the Hobbit movies, I wouldn't recommend watching them in the traditional way. Look up on your favourite search provider for "The Hobbit The Tolkien Edit", and grab one of those fan-made movies. Basically someone put all three movies into one and cut out all the content that's not actually in the book. Overall, that makes a far better movie than what we actually got, with about 10 hours of screentime cut to 4h30. That one would be worth a watch.

For everything Ring of Power related, don't even bother. Instead, I'd recommend reading The Silmarillion, if you haven't already.

Edit: corrected a name.

permalink parent save report block reply
▲ 2 ▼
– Mistercheif 2 points 3 years ago +2 / -0

Minor correction - it's Arwen in the movies that rescues Frodo, not Eowyn.

permalink parent save report block reply
▲ 2 ▼
– -Fender- 2 points 3 years ago +2 / -0

Christ, right. Guess I was tired yesterday. Thanks for that.

permalink parent save report block reply
▲ 1 ▼
– LastRights 1 point 3 years ago +1 / -0

Maple Films - JRR Tolkien's The Hobbit: A Fanedit by Dustin Lee?

permalink parent save report block reply
▲ 2 ▼
– -Fender- 2 points 3 years ago +2 / -0

Well, that could be one of them. Multiple different versions were made. I never really looked into all the differences between them, so I can't advise on which one is best. What I can say is that "The Hobbit - The Tolkien Edit" was the first one of them. Or at least, the first one I heard of, less than a year after the third movie came out.

permalink parent save report block reply
▲ 1 ▼
– FuckMcNuggets 1 point 3 years ago +1 / -0

My favourite I think is called the book edit, it fixes a few problems maple left in, in particular some contradicting dialogue.

permalink parent save report block reply

Original 8chan Links to Gamer Gate:

.

The main GG discussion is on the videogames board: https://8chan.moe/v/

.

GamerGate archive is at https://8chan.moe/gamergatehq/

.

GamerGate Wiki:

https://ggwiki.deepfreeze.it/index.php/Main_Page

. . . . . .

. . . . . .

Rules:

.

ONE: Do not advocate for illegal violence or post other illegal activity. (Be aware of your local laws.)

.

TWO: Don't threaten, harass, or impersonate users. Also: don't be a psycho. New users will be held to a higher standard.

.

THREE: Do not post porn.

.

FOUR: NSFW/NSFL content must be flaired NSFW.

.

FIVE: No vote manipulation. Do not break communities.win's features.

.

SIX: No spam or reposts. Do not make more than 5 threads a day.

.

SEVEN: Do not post falsehoods and hoaxes that are obvious to an uncontroversial degree.

. . . . . .

. . . . . .

Moderation Logs:

.

(Two different versions, Scored has more features and is cleaner, but .win let's you see a few more details in certain instances.)

  • Scored
  • .win

Moderators

  • DomitiusOfMassilia
  • C
  • BandageBandolier
  • CarmenOfSandiego
  • The_Shadow_of_Intent
  • SocraticMethod1
  • Kienan
  • Smith1980
Message the Moderators

Terms of Service | Privacy Policy

2026.02.01 - pv4fp (status)

Copyright © 2026.

Terms of Service | Privacy Policy