In Other News: Cheap Immigrants Are Being Imported to Replace U.S. Teachers :')
(www.breitbart.com)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (34)
sorted by:
Not really. AI hallucinates too much to be trusted to impart proper instruction in new knowledge. At best you'll have smart kids using AI to supplement the subpar instruction they get in a classroom, but they'll still need to sort out truth from tripping and the normal and dumb kids aren't going to be able to do that on their own.
You say that like most of the human teachers aren't completely detached from reality. AI can't replace a good teacher, but it can improve on the garbage we have now.
Perfection is the enemy of good as they say, it truly could be a good stopgap for the time it takes to purge the useless chaff and build up a proper cadre of educators.
That's why you use it as a supplement rather than an outright replacement. You still want to pursue the acquisition of good teachers but wholesale replacing them with AI is just as silly.
Bet nearly every one of these teachers probably uses AI to make the powerpoints they show students, assuming they don't just use what the department head gave them like a full time substitute teacher.
Damn, so what's a better alternative for the dumb ones then? Religious schools again?
Raise the bar for what we require of our educators, but in order to do that we need to restore both social status and the financial incentive to get good educators. It needs to not be a dead-end career that attracts dead-end individuals.
I remember back in high school I had the best physics teacher, who I want to say came to us from NASA or was otherwise a practicing physicist prior to ending up in the classroom. She knew her shit and was really good at teaching and keeping everyone engaged. Turns out a few years later she left the classroom to become an administrator because being a teacher just didn't pay well enough. That's an issue that needs to be tackled. You're gonna get a lot of knee-jerk responses about how we can't just dump more of the public coffers into a lefty captured public education system, but if you want better teachers you need to find a way to financially incentivize it. There's no getting around it, so people had best start brainstorming instead of digging their heels in.
Only problem is we need a way for it to be merit based pay so best teachers, best pay but how do you measure success in teaching?
You can say tests but you can easily teach to pass a test and still end up eith students with zero common sense. Need a good way to ensure good teachers have the pay they need, bad teachers not fit for it get zoned out.
Not by test outcomes, that's for sure. There's only so much a teacher can do when handed a classroom full of yard apes. My old man was high school biology teacher for over 30 years and his on the ground experience was that merit based pay didn't really work, so take that for what it's worth.
A lot of the hurdles classroom teachers have come from higher up the bureaucracy fucking with them. Stuff like adding more students into a class than is allowed or fucking with schedules and lesson prep materials without notice. It's not just the teachers that need to get sorted, it's the whole bloody system from top to bottom that is dysfunctional.