Nintendo Clamping Down Against Switch Emulation by Suing Yuzu - Techopse - Trading Enthusiasm for Anger
Nintendo, the company known for distributing pirated ROMs to consumers and issuing DMCA takedown notices against fan remakes and fangame projects, has filed a lawsuit against the popular Switch emulator Yuzu, seeking to shut down the program. Emulation has...
Yuzu shat the bed by putting things behind a Patreon paywall. That's why Nintendo went gunning for them.
If you want Nintendo to come a-knockin', make money off of your piracy.
I think they hate money makers and non-money makers equally. It's just that, when you make money, you can find out who the money is going to and they have a target they can crush.
Why is emu illegal, though? Some kind of DMCA bullshit? That seemed like kind of what Nintendo was alluding to by saying "decryption."
Emulation isn't, but newer consoles require BIOS images to run, and those would be protected, unless they're custom. Maybe YUZU is distributing them?
Not all Switch games rely on the Switch's firmware/BIOS. However all(retail) of them are encrypted and you need to either find the keys elsewhere or dump them from your own Switch(assuming you can run homebrew on it)
Could be even if they're not distributing the BIOS binaries that distributing tools to actually use them constitutes enabling circumvention, which you can be sued for separately. Like the people that first enabled DVD playback on Linux.
I really don't know; that's why I was asking.
Officially, per the DMCA, if a company encrypts their product in any way shape, or form, that counts as a written notice of them refusing to allow you to copy the product. Now, this directly conflicts with the DMCA saying that any home user, library, or educational institution can make backup copies, but since when has the law ever broken in the favor of the normal person?
Yep, the DMCA pretty much says if the mfr employs encryption the mfr can set out any use scheme they want and you have to obey it. It's like a EULA that you don't have to sign. It's typical and telling of the US congress that the only time they'll actually pass legislation is to screw people over for the benefit of Big Media.
Honestly, applies in many similar situations. There's fair use to a certain extent, but profiting off of possible theft is guaranteeing yourself a lawsuit.