A jew who isn't Jewish isn't a jew. He's typically a Leftist pretending to be a jew. The core element to a jew is his Judaism. It is his culture, his language, his history, his religion, his family, his friends, his community, his home, and his... uh, well, tradition.
Britain is a political entity that is comprised of 4 kingdoms, one of which is England. An englishman is necessarily British, and that is because England is part of Britain, and an englishman's culture, language, history, religion, family, friends, community, home, and traditions are English (which are thus British).
A non-English Englishman doesn't exist. A man living in England, who is a Pakistani Muslim, who opposes the existence of England, demands the construction of an Islamic Caliphate, doesn't speak English, doesn't interact outside his Islamist community, can not be English.
Removing the core element that defines the object is to remove the definition of the thing itself.
White on the other had, like all racial constructs, is a wildly broad construct defined almost entirely within a political sphere. It has no shared religion, tradition, language, culture, history, or even geography. While biological substrata exist ("Biological Race" if you will), these don't define the religion, tradition, language, culture, history, or geography.
You can have a white englishman. You can have a white jew. You can have a black englishman. You can have a black jew. You can't have a russian englishman, nor an athiest jew.
A jew who isn't Jewish isn't a jew. He's typically a Leftist pretending to be a jew.
So "white people suck, but I'm not white, I'm Jewish" bigots are actually white and not Jewish?
Can you go argue with them about that instead of mincing words about it here?
For the record, I don't care what those types call themselves or what anyone else calls them. Leftist subversive works fine. But until "it's not ok to lump all white people into a category of evil oppressors" is as culturally enforced as "it's not ok to lump all Jewish people into a category of evil oppressors," I'm not going to be terribly bothered when the gander gets the goose's sauce. We're marching down the path to another round of ethnic genocides and if I'm forced to pick a side in this stupid game, I'm going with the one that doesn't hate me and I'm not going to feel guilty about it.
So "white people suck, but I'm not white, I'm Jewish" bigots are actually white and not Jewish? Can you go argue with them about that instead of mincing words about it here?
They're typically Leftists. However, they aren't here. I am here, and thus my opinions are here too. If they do, one day, show up, you can see me argue with them. Something along the lines of "It's not that you're not a real jew; it's that you're not a jew at all, you're just a globalist Leftist that belongs nowhere, and has no people, and doesn't deserve any."
Leftists can culturally enforce whatever they want, and I intend to shove it back in their face: like using "jew" as a shield.
Religions and ethnicities are different.
You can be British and not English, and vice versa.
You can be a Jew and not Jewish, same as.
Those aren't anything like each other.
A jew who isn't Jewish isn't a jew. He's typically a Leftist pretending to be a jew. The core element to a jew is his Judaism. It is his culture, his language, his history, his religion, his family, his friends, his community, his home, and his... uh, well, tradition.
Britain is a political entity that is comprised of 4 kingdoms, one of which is England. An englishman is necessarily British, and that is because England is part of Britain, and an englishman's culture, language, history, religion, family, friends, community, home, and traditions are English (which are thus British).
A non-English Englishman doesn't exist. A man living in England, who is a Pakistani Muslim, who opposes the existence of England, demands the construction of an Islamic Caliphate, doesn't speak English, doesn't interact outside his Islamist community, can not be English.
Being English is core to being an englishman.
Being Jewish is core to being a jew.
Removing the core element that defines the object is to remove the definition of the thing itself.
White on the other had, like all racial constructs, is a wildly broad construct defined almost entirely within a political sphere. It has no shared religion, tradition, language, culture, history, or even geography. While biological substrata exist ("Biological Race" if you will), these don't define the religion, tradition, language, culture, history, or geography.
You can have a white englishman. You can have a white jew. You can have a black englishman. You can have a black jew. You can't have a russian englishman, nor an athiest jew.
So "white people suck, but I'm not white, I'm Jewish" bigots are actually white and not Jewish?
Can you go argue with them about that instead of mincing words about it here?
For the record, I don't care what those types call themselves or what anyone else calls them. Leftist subversive works fine. But until "it's not ok to lump all white people into a category of evil oppressors" is as culturally enforced as "it's not ok to lump all Jewish people into a category of evil oppressors," I'm not going to be terribly bothered when the gander gets the goose's sauce. We're marching down the path to another round of ethnic genocides and if I'm forced to pick a side in this stupid game, I'm going with the one that doesn't hate me and I'm not going to feel guilty about it.
They're typically Leftists. However, they aren't here. I am here, and thus my opinions are here too. If they do, one day, show up, you can see me argue with them. Something along the lines of "It's not that you're not a real jew; it's that you're not a jew at all, you're just a globalist Leftist that belongs nowhere, and has no people, and doesn't deserve any."
Leftists can culturally enforce whatever they want, and I intend to shove it back in their face: like using "jew" as a shield.
Fine, but the underlying problem that you're trying to solve with these arguments isn't 'here' either.