We're having to go to paternal grandfather to claim Jewish?
And attending synagogue.
but paternal grandfather is Jewish,
But also, yes. Things pass from the father in my culture. What do I care what they say about matrilineal bullshit. It's patrilineal in the bible, and patrilineal in my culture.
And you say 1 grandfather is silly. But if there were a guy with an african grandfather, you'd call him 'black' in a heartbeat.
He attendED synagogue (past tense) (says he doesn't practice Judaism today) and sides with Palestine and hates Israel and Zionism. So you have an ally there in him.
If a "Christian attended church" when they were 12, but spouted all the leftist crap, would you call them a representation of Christianity? Or would you rightly conclude they're a person of the garbage culture, claiming a Christian label without any consequential affect on them?
is Christianity an ethnoreligion? Or are you ignoring the differences.
Even without that, I don't know many non jews who attended a synagogue. Maybe once as some misguided outreach thing from a liberal group, but having a synagoge, no. Look, he's jewish, you know it, you're just arguing with it because you've dug a hole.
And also again, if things pass from the father, then you should say that a Jew, if it can be found out that their paternal grandfather was Irish, you should call them a European by that logic?
And attending synagogue.
But also, yes. Things pass from the father in my culture. What do I care what they say about matrilineal bullshit. It's patrilineal in the bible, and patrilineal in my culture.
And you say 1 grandfather is silly. But if there were a guy with an african grandfather, you'd call him 'black' in a heartbeat.
Don't bother arguing with the judeophile. Just look at his post history.
For instance: https://scored.co/c/TheDonald/p/1ASZVknqHE/this-not-the-trump-we-voted-for/c
Or: https://scored.co/c/TheDonald/p/1ASG0IqasG/im-surprised-that-the-left-surpr/c
He is JDIF through and through. Proabably Giz's sleeper.
Heh the writing style is different, but also writes long autistic paragraphs about jews aren't jews
He attendED synagogue (past tense) (says he doesn't practice Judaism today) and sides with Palestine and hates Israel and Zionism. So you have an ally there in him.
If a "Christian attended church" when they were 12, but spouted all the leftist crap, would you call them a representation of Christianity? Or would you rightly conclude they're a person of the garbage culture, claiming a Christian label without any consequential affect on them?
is Christianity an ethnoreligion? Or are you ignoring the differences.
Even without that, I don't know many non jews who attended a synagogue. Maybe once as some misguided outreach thing from a liberal group, but having a synagoge, no. Look, he's jewish, you know it, you're just arguing with it because you've dug a hole.
No, I'm arguing because I reject the framework narrative around the Jews.
So this guy is an isolated example, an exception even?
And also again, if things pass from the father, then you should say that a Jew, if it can be found out that their paternal grandfather was Irish, you should call them a European by that logic?
Or does it only cut one way?
It's more of a drop rule with the paternal side being more important really.
Carl Benjamin apparently is like 1/4th African. I don't call him black. I'd call him white.
Egyptian or something? Else I don't believe it.