I don't understand ANY argument for conscription. Of all the laws on the books that are still "acceptable" in modernity from even the "progressive" crowd, the one that perplexes me the most is conscription.
For me, it's just so simple: If a government needs to force people to fight for the government then the government has no right to exist. A legitimate government should be able to raise a fully volunteer army because all the citizens the government represents wants to fight to defend this government.
Just think about it for a moment. Supposedly some evil enemy is coming to rape your women and kill all the men or enslave everyone by taking their rights away. Everyone should want to defend against that, no? If someone doesn't volunteer to fight against that then clearly they've decided that rape and death is better than... rape and death? Or, perhaps they've decided they can still live without dying for a country and they'd rather this conclusion.
How can anyone justify using force to force something to go to war and die against their will?
I hate the concept of conscription so much I think anyone who suggests it should be hanged, tbh. You want people to fight for you? Offer them an incentive then.
So, not allowing yourself to be conscripted, or joining and fragging some zogbot officers would be contributing to the common defense.
That isn't what OP said.
He said there is no argument for conscription. Plain as day, that is his default statement here.
Well, the entire history of humanity belies that claim.
His statement at the top looks to be describing the modern day.
Not in the slightest, as best I can tell. He even makes some allusions to older forms of war such as raping and carrying off women and children.
He made a historical allegory and then proceeded to ignore it and pout about it.
But in fact there are plenty of historical examples, more than not, of a levy, conscription, draft or what the fuck ever you want to call it, that were not only moral but necessary.
Firstly because the idea of war does not demand or even allow for the nonsense group consensus that he claims is necessary, and secondly because the average prole/peasant throughout history has always had to be kicked and whipped into getting off his ass. Because the average person is by and large worthless.
Dude isn't arguing all that clearly, but that's the impression I got from it.
Older? It's literally happening right now, except they don't have to carry them far since ZOG is providing the rapists with taxpayer-funded housing.