So you're telling me that after the war was over, and the deed was done, they created studies to justify what they had done? That is not exactly unsurprising. Also, 500K - even if accurate - is still a long way from 5 million.
You accuse me of not reading things properly? That was losses of Allied troops, that's where the 100K you mentioned came from. You really think Japan could have been over-run with 100K civilians dead? The bombers alone killed far more than that.
They did studies after the war to check how accurate (or not!) their plans were. They had no need to "justify" anything, they'd won.
It wasn't until after the war they learned just how well prepared Japan was for exactly where the invasions would come from. It would have been a bloodbath. The estimates for Japan's military losses would have been at least 800K, nearly all their troops in the southern island. Civilian losses would have been at least 3 million, again just for that first phase of Downfall. A minimum of 4.3M just for Olympic.
The rest of your blathering is far too stupid to deserve a reply other than 🤣
You accuse me of not reading things properly? That was losses of Allied troops, that's where the 100K you mentioned came from.
That was what I mentioned because that is all they care about.
They had no need to "justify" anything, they'd won.
That's when you justify your actions... when the deed is done. Do you really think they'd admit afterwards that they used the most terrible weapons and it was completely unnecessary?
It's like your people being concentration camp guards for yet another genocide that was completely unnecessary, like the one in Gaza.
The rest of your blathering is far too stupid to deserve a reply other than 🤣
Not the first time you've lost a debate to me, and it won't be the last. Why would you even start sh*t with me, only to humiliate yourself like this? Calling a Major General 'some bureaucrat'? Endorsing calls to spread epidemics? Being unable to read two separate sections? No wonder you're getting your ass kicked HARD by Uncle Vova. Rightly so.
"Lost" 😜 You are delusional.
The only way you've "won" is by twisting facts until they mean the opposite of reality, then screaming the lies over and over like a 7 year-old having a tantrum. You just did it again in that comment!
When you get something correct I've acknowledged it, but that still makes you angry somehow. Oh well.
The fact that you are unable to cite any fact that I 'twisted' is proof positive that you, yes, got whipped.
When you get something correct I've acknowledged it,
No, you didn't even acknowledge you own inability to read your second language after Ukrainian, for example your false claim that I said Dresden was A-bombed.
Here's one: why do you IMAGINE I can speak Ukrainian? My ancestors have been in Canada speaking English for 130 years now... idiot. And when they (going further back) were in Ukraine? They spoke German, because they were German Mennonites. IDK how many times I've told you this. 4? 5? Yet you still twist it and lie. There's another fine example.
I ask you many clear and simple questions, you ignore them and spout distracting gibberish. Or you answer something completely different, twisted by your stupidity. You're amazingly consistent at it. Not just with me, when others bother to talk to you it's the exact same pattern.
You accuse me of not reading things properly? That was losses of Allied troops, that's where the 100K you mentioned came from. You really think Japan could have been over-run with 100K civilians dead? The bombers alone killed far more than that.
They did studies after the war to check how accurate (or not!) their plans were. They had no need to "justify" anything, they'd won.
It wasn't until after the war they learned just how well prepared Japan was for exactly where the invasions would come from. It would have been a bloodbath. The estimates for Japan's military losses would have been at least 800K, nearly all their troops in the southern island. Civilian losses would have been at least 3 million, again just for that first phase of Downfall. A minimum of 4.3M just for Olympic.
The rest of your blathering is far too stupid to deserve a reply other than 🤣
That was what I mentioned because that is all they care about.
That's when you justify your actions... when the deed is done. Do you really think they'd admit afterwards that they used the most terrible weapons and it was completely unnecessary?
It's like your people being concentration camp guards for yet another genocide that was completely unnecessary, like the one in Gaza.
Not the first time you've lost a debate to me, and it won't be the last. Why would you even start sh*t with me, only to humiliate yourself like this? Calling a Major General 'some bureaucrat'? Endorsing calls to spread epidemics? Being unable to read two separate sections? No wonder you're getting your ass kicked HARD by Uncle Vova. Rightly so.
"Lost" 😜 You are delusional.
The only way you've "won" is by twisting facts until they mean the opposite of reality, then screaming the lies over and over like a 7 year-old having a tantrum. You just did it again in that comment!
When you get something correct I've acknowledged it, but that still makes you angry somehow. Oh well.
You prefer 'got whipped'?
The fact that you are unable to cite any fact that I 'twisted' is proof positive that you, yes, got whipped.
No, you didn't even acknowledge you own inability to read your second language after Ukrainian, for example your false claim that I said Dresden was A-bombed.
Here's one: why do you IMAGINE I can speak Ukrainian? My ancestors have been in Canada speaking English for 130 years now... idiot. And when they (going further back) were in Ukraine? They spoke German, because they were German Mennonites. IDK how many times I've told you this. 4? 5? Yet you still twist it and lie. There's another fine example.
I ask you many clear and simple questions, you ignore them and spout distracting gibberish. Or you answer something completely different, twisted by your stupidity. You're amazingly consistent at it. Not just with me, when others bother to talk to you it's the exact same pattern.