Other villains aren't so great, either. In my view, Superman should mostly deal with 'out of space' threats. It would make the character roster more promising. Superman is overpowered. So it stands to reason that he should deal with world ending threats. Most earth-based villains aren't capable of achieving such a feat.
Here are additional notable Superman villains, excluding Darkseid, Doomsday, Lex Luthor, Brainiac, and Parasite:
Livewire: A former broadcaster struck by lightning, gaining electrical powers that make her a serious threat to Superman. She can transform into living energy, manipulate electricity, and has come close to killing Superman
.
Toyman: A villain who uses deadly toys and gadgets to challenge Superman. Often underrated but dangerous, he has a creepy and inventive modus operandi
.
Silver Banshee: A supernatural foe with a deadly sonic scream that can kill if she knows a victim’s name. She nearly defeated Superman with her voice-based powers
.
Master Jailer: A villain with the ability to create containment units and later revealed to know Superman’s secret identity. He uses his powers to imprison and trap others, posing unique challenges
.
Hobby Robber: An obscure villain who steals people’s hobbies and related items, including Superman’s clock collection. Though minor, he represents a quirky and unusual threat
.
Blue Matt: A lesser-known villain who can turn himself and objects invisible, making him a tricky adversary
.
Cyborg Superman (Hank Henshaw): A tragic and dark villain who is a cyborg clone of Superman, driven by hatred and revenge. His half-machine, half-Superman appearance is visually striking and menacing
.
Ultra-Humanite: A brilliant mad scientist who transfers his mind into different bodies, including an albino gorilla, using intellect and physical prowess against Superman
.
Mister Mxyzptlk: A mischievous imp with reality-warping powers, providing a whimsical but challenging foe who bends reality itself
.
Most only work as second or fourth film villains, or even the setup pieces, after establishing what Superman can do.
Livewire was a hilarious disaster in the animated cartoon where an angry young woman gained superpowers and immediately started trying to kill people. Imp couldn't write a more deranged character if he tried. Any live action adaptation would suffer hard from having to avoid being too accurate to the cartoon version simply so it doesn't get torn to shreds for how awful the character is as a person, even before going full homicidal maniac after getting powers.
Toyman would only work if existing knowledge of Superman's powers was in place, otherwise Superman would just look through the entire city and find Toyman in under a minute.
Silver Banshee is a very, very boring superpowered character that would only serve as a minion or setup piece of something worse.
Master Jailer would trap Superman all of once then get overpowered because again he doesn't know anywhere near enough to stop someone as powerful as Superman without knowing what he can do. The most likely scenario would be trapping Superman as if it was anyone else, expecting that to work, finding out it doesn't, and then being taken out at superspeed before getting a chance to try again.
Hobby Robber: As you mention it would be a minor threat, and again requires Superman to already be established to even have a hobby collection in the first place to steal from.
Blue Matt: Invisibility doesn't stop Kryptonians.
Cyborg Superman generally only pops up after Doomsdays and any Death of Superman story, so still needs Superman established. Same with Metallo, having a character based someone, or designed to counter that someone, only works when said someone has existed for long enough for it to matter.
Ultra-Humanite isn't one I can see happening if anything Flash related ever comes about, he's too similar to Grodd.
5th dimensional Imp also only works when Superman is already established, and most likely as a 4th film comedy piece after any initial origin story film 1, gritty moral dilemma film 2, and then final waltz big fight film 3.
Edit: If Suicide Squad 2: Shitty Boogaloo hadn't used Starro I would have suggested that since it's not actually a problem you can punch most of the time since that would kill the hosts.
Master jailer could make for a good movie that shows Superman is intelligent and not just a flying brick. Parasite could also be cool for a sequel that has the supporting cast trying to find and help Superman. As he was captured by parasite. The animated series from the 90s was awesome.
That's how Parasite often gets used, after any initial outing that gets to set the stage and have Superman fight off some problem just to let the world know how powerful he is.
At that point you have various groups trying to replicate him, imprison him, blackmail him, fight him, or steal his powers.
The above list more or less means villains such as Cyborg Superman, The Preserver, Lex, Mongul, and Parasite respectively.
Other villains aren't so great, either. In my view, Superman should mostly deal with 'out of space' threats. It would make the character roster more promising. Superman is overpowered. So it stands to reason that he should deal with world ending threats. Most earth-based villains aren't capable of achieving such a feat.
Here are additional notable Superman villains, excluding Darkseid, Doomsday, Lex Luthor, Brainiac, and Parasite:
.
Toyman: A villain who uses deadly toys and gadgets to challenge Superman. Often underrated but dangerous, he has a creepy and inventive modus operandi
.
Silver Banshee: A supernatural foe with a deadly sonic scream that can kill if she knows a victim’s name. She nearly defeated Superman with her voice-based powers
.
Master Jailer: A villain with the ability to create containment units and later revealed to know Superman’s secret identity. He uses his powers to imprison and trap others, posing unique challenges
.
Hobby Robber: An obscure villain who steals people’s hobbies and related items, including Superman’s clock collection. Though minor, he represents a quirky and unusual threat
.
Blue Matt: A lesser-known villain who can turn himself and objects invisible, making him a tricky adversary
.
Cyborg Superman (Hank Henshaw): A tragic and dark villain who is a cyborg clone of Superman, driven by hatred and revenge. His half-machine, half-Superman appearance is visually striking and menacing
.
Ultra-Humanite: A brilliant mad scientist who transfers his mind into different bodies, including an albino gorilla, using intellect and physical prowess against Superman
.
Mister Mxyzptlk: A mischievous imp with reality-warping powers, providing a whimsical but challenging foe who bends reality itself .
Most only work as second or fourth film villains, or even the setup pieces, after establishing what Superman can do.
Livewire was a hilarious disaster in the animated cartoon where an angry young woman gained superpowers and immediately started trying to kill people. Imp couldn't write a more deranged character if he tried. Any live action adaptation would suffer hard from having to avoid being too accurate to the cartoon version simply so it doesn't get torn to shreds for how awful the character is as a person, even before going full homicidal maniac after getting powers.
Toyman would only work if existing knowledge of Superman's powers was in place, otherwise Superman would just look through the entire city and find Toyman in under a minute.
Silver Banshee is a very, very boring superpowered character that would only serve as a minion or setup piece of something worse.
Master Jailer would trap Superman all of once then get overpowered because again he doesn't know anywhere near enough to stop someone as powerful as Superman without knowing what he can do. The most likely scenario would be trapping Superman as if it was anyone else, expecting that to work, finding out it doesn't, and then being taken out at superspeed before getting a chance to try again.
Hobby Robber: As you mention it would be a minor threat, and again requires Superman to already be established to even have a hobby collection in the first place to steal from.
Blue Matt: Invisibility doesn't stop Kryptonians.
Cyborg Superman generally only pops up after Doomsdays and any Death of Superman story, so still needs Superman established. Same with Metallo, having a character based someone, or designed to counter that someone, only works when said someone has existed for long enough for it to matter.
Ultra-Humanite isn't one I can see happening if anything Flash related ever comes about, he's too similar to Grodd.
5th dimensional Imp also only works when Superman is already established, and most likely as a 4th film comedy piece after any initial origin story film 1, gritty moral dilemma film 2, and then final waltz big fight film 3.
Edit: If Suicide Squad 2: Shitty Boogaloo hadn't used Starro I would have suggested that since it's not actually a problem you can punch most of the time since that would kill the hosts.
Master jailer could make for a good movie that shows Superman is intelligent and not just a flying brick. Parasite could also be cool for a sequel that has the supporting cast trying to find and help Superman. As he was captured by parasite. The animated series from the 90s was awesome.
That's how Parasite often gets used, after any initial outing that gets to set the stage and have Superman fight off some problem just to let the world know how powerful he is.
At that point you have various groups trying to replicate him, imprison him, blackmail him, fight him, or steal his powers.
The above list more or less means villains such as Cyborg Superman, The Preserver, Lex, Mongul, and Parasite respectively.
It lacked the spark that the animated Batman series had.