Some stories are true that never happened
(media.kotakuinaction2.win)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (28)
sorted by:
If you're so historically ignorant that you need to invent fake scenes to demonstrate the sadism of National Socialists, then you need to shut up and not make a historical drama. Especially when actual Nazi hunters existed on top of all of this.
From stuffing people into a church and burning everyone alive (and machine gunning the people who escaped) in the Oradour-sur-Glane massacre, to officers tying an American POW to the hood of their car during the Battle of The Bulge because they thought it was funny, to the absolutely notorious Dirlewanger Brigade, there are no shortages of atrocities to pick from, or "inspire a scene from" since we're going with a alternate reality where Hitler survives the war.
Making shit up as you go, without any reference to reality, while being totally ignorant of what actually happened, benefits only the worst possible people.
Not to mention, that cross-examining Hitler scene is clearly written by someone who had no reference to Adolph Hitler, as none of Hitler's actual arguments or perspectives from his books or speeches were clearly used.
Buddy - not once in the 80 years since WW2 have hitlers “actual arguments” or “perspectives from his books” made it into a single one of the (gorillions of) pieces of media about him and the nazis produced in the mainstream - or can you think of any?
Downfall.
Wasn't really an ideological piece, but more of a drama.
Which part of downfall explains hitlers “actual arguments” or “perspectives from his book”?
Like I said, it's not an ideological treatise. It's a drama. It doesn't present his perspective regarding his family, the war, his issues with the military, his bizarre and precarious command position in the end of the war, etc.
Does it look like these lies and exaggerations are only benefiting the Nazis? Because I could swear the people befitting most from all of this are members of a certain tribe, and they ain’t Nazis.
That's what he said!
Seriously though there are no Nazis, but the amount of new "noticers" the absolute ridiculousness of this propaganda creates must benefit vehement anti-jews a little bit, by proximity. In other words this will cause more people to start going to alternative sources of info, read up on the USS Liberty even though the memes warned them against it, and a few of them join the anons on 4chan who say a real holocaust would have been a good thing.
But you're right most consumers will just eat it up and won't even hear the criticism so it might be effective to some degree. Less so than it used to be because people aren't watching this shit.
Comment Reported for: Rule 16 - Identity Attacks
Comment Approved: This actually doesn't do that.
Creating your own personal holocaust fantasy doesn't benefit jews, the same way creating a rape fantasy doesn't benefit women, the same way white supremacist fantasizing doesn't benefit blacks, the same way pretending child drag shows are normal doesn't benefit people with gender dysphoria.
Instead it begets: The Pence Rule, Scott Adams memes, declining tolerance for gays. Blowback exists.