That assumes that Orthodox jews in Israel give a shit what American jews think. American jews that aren't religious, keep supporting Palestine, and have this whole "open boarders" idea.

If there's anything that Israel has proven in it's existence: it's that it doesn't give a shit what anyone else thinks. From the quote I wrote you, I'd bet it's not an impossibility considering how the more numerous American jews keep trying to fund political opposition in Israel to keep that from happening.