It's really hard to know how based a justice will be before they're actually writing opinions. Trump actually did better than Reagan and the Bushes. O'Connor pulled the same shit that Roberts does today, and Kennedy was a fag lover. Scalia was the only based Reagan appointee. People often forget the Bush Sr appointed a justice other than Thomas: Souter straight up stabbed Bush in the back and joined the commie caucus. Kavanaugh is the only Trump appointee out of 3 who's total shit. Gorsuch does retarded shit on occasion but he's usually solid. The jury is still out on ACB IMO but I haven't seen anything totally awful from her. So yeah, it's not very fair to judge a president by their SCOTUS picks absent evidence of malice. Justices often do things the presidents who appointed them never expected.