"Fact" one is an axiom, and "facts" three and four are moral pronouncements. None of which depend on the correctness of "fact" two.
Even if the ACLU accepted that "fact" two was false it would have no effect on the validity or invalidity of the other statements, because they aren't dependent on the correctness of "fact" two.
"Fact" 3, like "fact" 2, is objectively false. The bio girls who lose or drop in placing because of the men involved don't benefit, they clearly and undeniably suffer.
1 and 4 are simply opinions, which one could have regardless of any actual facts.
Archive of their awful thread: https://archive.is/9FlBq
FACT ONE: Trans girls are girls.
FACT TWO: Trans athletes do not have an unfair advantage in sports.
FACT THREE: Including trans athletes will benefit everyone.
[citation needed]
FACT FOUR: Trans people belong on the same teams as other students.
So I now must demand all you transphobic bigots stop, you've been shown UNDENIABLE PROOF.
https://twitter.com/Lauren_Southern/status/1357319617295781889
"Fact" one is an axiom, and "facts" three and four are moral pronouncements. None of which depend on the correctness of "fact" two.
Even if the ACLU accepted that "fact" two was false it would have no effect on the validity or invalidity of the other statements, because they aren't dependent on the correctness of "fact" two.
"Fact" 3, like "fact" 2, is objectively false. The bio girls who lose or drop in placing because of the men involved don't benefit, they clearly and undeniably suffer.
1 and 4 are simply opinions, which one could have regardless of any actual facts.
1 is objectively false as well. Definitions can not be altered to mean whatever the speaker wishes them to mean.
Now try proving that in a courtroom.
Unless the judge was a hateful bigot, how could they disagree?
This court requires you to announce your pronouns, xir.
1 : Not really.
2 : Not in men's, that's for sure.
3 : Well it'll benefit everyone sane, as women's sport finally dies.
4 : Sure, why not. Only women will be mad and they voted for this out of blind hatred for us.