Was it? An overachieving minority population had already existed in Russia in the Germans, but they were never pogromed. What gives?
Were Jews even overachievers? Weren't they just very poor peasants? There's a reason everywhere Jews fled the pogroms to, they created an anti-Jewish backlash.
The Jewish guy Karl Marx? Yeah that guy.
Why are they only Jews when it suits you? By your standards, the Apostles were all Jews (and evil).
Either we do the reddit source? source?? thing or we go from the premise.
Hahaha. You're actually posting unsubstantiated claims, which you believe but have no idea why you believe them, and have the temerity to attack other people for asking you to back it up.
NO, I don't present evidence for my claims! We work from my unsubstantiated claims OR you're a Redditor.
No wonder the right is such a total, complete and total mess.
I find it ludicrous that even if you accepted that most Communist intellectuals were Jewish, that wouldn't prove Communism is a Jewish movement. I don't even know how that makes sense.
I find your position ludicrous, because there would still be nothing inherently 'Jewish' about Communism.
No substantiation? You're becoming lazy even by your standards.
Yes, the apostles were Jews, but they were not evil. Why? Because they did not do evil. Obviously.
I guess Christianity was a 'Jewish movement' according to you then.
That makes utterly no sense.
It makes perfect sense. I'm sure you'll cry about Redditors again, but this is the fallacy of composition. There is nothing Jewish about communism, in fact, it is very anti-religious.
No substantiation? You're becoming lazy even by your standards.
source? Fiddler on the Roof?
I guess Christianity was a 'Jewish movement' according to you then.
Yes, Christianity was indeed a Jewish movement because God used the Jews. People have a problem admitting that here but it's fairly simple.
It makes perfect sense. I'm sure you'll cry about Redditors again, but this is the fallacy of composition. There is nothing Jewish about communism, in fact, it is very anti-religious.
Lol to think that the influence of ethnoreligious culture ends when you stop believing in God is just so naive. Ashkenazis are atheist by default.
Source? What I already gave you, but you apparently didn't listen. There were strong anti-Jewish reactions everywhere precisely because Eastern Europeans Jews were so poor and uncultured.
Yes, Christianity was indeed a Jewish movement because God used the Jews. People have a problem admitting that here but it's fairly simple.
But that suggests that there is something fundamentally Jewish about Christianity. Also, this makes quite little sense. So communism and Christianity are both Jewish? They're polar opposites.
Lol to think that the influence of ethnoreligious culture ends when you stop believing in God is just so naive. Ashkenazis are atheist by default.
OK, so Marxism shows the influence of Jeiwshness because his father was a Jew who converted to Christianity, but by that standard, it's much less Jewish than Christianity.
I don't think you have your definitions or your thinking straight. What does it mean for an ideology or movement to "be Jewish"? Does it say something about the ideology or movement itself? If not, then isn't it tautological to say "communism is Jewish because [allegedly] most communists were Jews?"
Were Jews even overachievers? Weren't they just very poor peasants? There's a reason everywhere Jews fled the pogroms to, they created an anti-Jewish backlash.
Why are they only Jews when it suits you? By your standards, the Apostles were all Jews (and evil).
Hahaha. You're actually posting unsubstantiated claims, which you believe but have no idea why you believe them, and have the temerity to attack other people for asking you to back it up.
NO, I don't present evidence for my claims! We work from my unsubstantiated claims OR you're a Redditor.
No wonder the right is such a total, complete and total mess.
I find your position ludicrous, because there would still be nothing inherently 'Jewish' about Communism.
Simply, no.
Yes, the apostles were Jews, but they were not evil. Why? Because they did not do evil. Obviously.
That makes utterly no sense.
No substantiation? You're becoming lazy even by your standards.
I guess Christianity was a 'Jewish movement' according to you then.
It makes perfect sense. I'm sure you'll cry about Redditors again, but this is the fallacy of composition. There is nothing Jewish about communism, in fact, it is very anti-religious.
source? Fiddler on the Roof?
Yes, Christianity was indeed a Jewish movement because God used the Jews. People have a problem admitting that here but it's fairly simple.
Lol to think that the influence of ethnoreligious culture ends when you stop believing in God is just so naive. Ashkenazis are atheist by default.
Source? What I already gave you, but you apparently didn't listen. There were strong anti-Jewish reactions everywhere precisely because Eastern Europeans Jews were so poor and uncultured.
But that suggests that there is something fundamentally Jewish about Christianity. Also, this makes quite little sense. So communism and Christianity are both Jewish? They're polar opposites.
OK, so Marxism shows the influence of Jeiwshness because his father was a Jew who converted to Christianity, but by that standard, it's much less Jewish than Christianity.
I don't think you have your definitions or your thinking straight. What does it mean for an ideology or movement to "be Jewish"? Does it say something about the ideology or movement itself? If not, then isn't it tautological to say "communism is Jewish because [allegedly] most communists were Jews?"