What about National Socialism in which they were race first, socialist and nationalist is propaganda vs. ideology? I mean, that seems pretty solidly what they were...
They weren't "race first, with minor socialism". That's the propaganda they fed to the useful idiots. They were a sociopathic leftist cabal leading a horde of useful idiots into an authoritarian death cult that ended in the total destruction of their nation.
In window dressing they claimed difference from communists. In function they were the same.
What part of "planned central government control of economy, purges and war" doesn't sound like communism to you? The part where they pretended to be looking out for their people (communists also pretend that). Which was the propaganda, as demonstrated by the results.
As well, Hitler instigated WW2 alongside the Soviets. Had he actually been benevolent and concerned for his people's welfare he wouldn't have worked with the communists or started invading other nations. He and Zelensky are guilty of similar crimes when it comes to fucking your own people for personal gain.
Are you that ignorant? In actual function, the nazis were just another authoritarian leftist dictatorship that left nothing but ruin in it's wake.
You seem pretty closed off to any discussion on the matter but in case you are open to it, here would be the points of contention:
The National Socialist government ironically had less control over the economy than modern Western governments do today. Remember, there's War Economy and Non-War Economy. War economies are always more centrally planned and the American Economy during WWII was highly: Planned Central Government Control of Economy. I'm not suggesting the National Socialists didn't control the economy because they did but it wasn't extreme like the USSR. I'm also not suggesting it was good in the manner they did control things either because many of the socialist policies like deferring funds from single people to married couples to buy houses is not a good thing. However that policy is right out of the playbook in the USA where there's subsidies to married couples, Hungary and Poland also have similar policies. All Western governments today control the economy more than the National Socialists did.
Purges and war. Keep in mind the USA has engaged in significantly more wars than the National Socialists did and is responsible for far more "purges" than the National Socialists were. Of course, the National Socialists lost before their empire started so over the long-term, it's entirely 100% speculation.
It's quite arguable who instigated WWII. Did Russia or Ukraine start the Ukraine war? Putin claims it was the West and the West claims it was Putin. I tend to side with Putin and believe the West instigated it and the West instigated it much in the same manner as how the West instigated Hitler into war. If you want the full details though of why Hitler had to go to war, the short answer is that Hitler wanted to industrialize Germany which required excess food supply from rural people to support city people. Germany did not have enough food to support their growing city population because the West stopped trading with Germany because Germany stopped paying the reparations and interest on their debt which was arguably not something that was fair for them to be paying in the first place. So it really depends where you stand here. if the West traded food to Germany to sustain their industrial development, then Hitler wouldn't have felt forced into going to war to claim more agriculture land to boost his food supply for his industrialization. The Soviets had a similar issue but the Soviet solution was to kill all the rural Christians instead then steal their food. Less mouths to feed and free food.
Lastly, the only reason Hitler left ruin in his wake is because the West attacked him and caused ruin. The real villains of WWII are the Soviets, Britain and the Americans. France also but they were worthless anyhow. The allies are the bad guy not the good guys. Today you live under the Authoritarian Leftist Dictatorship of the West.
What about National Socialism in which they were race first, socialist and nationalist is propaganda vs. ideology? I mean, that seems pretty solidly what they were...
They weren't "race first, with minor socialism". That's the propaganda they fed to the useful idiots. They were a sociopathic leftist cabal leading a horde of useful idiots into an authoritarian death cult that ended in the total destruction of their nation.
In window dressing they claimed difference from communists. In function they were the same.
Are you sure what you just described isn't the propaganda?
What part of "planned central government control of economy, purges and war" doesn't sound like communism to you? The part where they pretended to be looking out for their people (communists also pretend that). Which was the propaganda, as demonstrated by the results.
As well, Hitler instigated WW2 alongside the Soviets. Had he actually been benevolent and concerned for his people's welfare he wouldn't have worked with the communists or started invading other nations. He and Zelensky are guilty of similar crimes when it comes to fucking your own people for personal gain.
Are you that ignorant? In actual function, the nazis were just another authoritarian leftist dictatorship that left nothing but ruin in it's wake.
You seem pretty closed off to any discussion on the matter but in case you are open to it, here would be the points of contention:
The National Socialist government ironically had less control over the economy than modern Western governments do today. Remember, there's War Economy and Non-War Economy. War economies are always more centrally planned and the American Economy during WWII was highly: Planned Central Government Control of Economy. I'm not suggesting the National Socialists didn't control the economy because they did but it wasn't extreme like the USSR. I'm also not suggesting it was good in the manner they did control things either because many of the socialist policies like deferring funds from single people to married couples to buy houses is not a good thing. However that policy is right out of the playbook in the USA where there's subsidies to married couples, Hungary and Poland also have similar policies. All Western governments today control the economy more than the National Socialists did.
Purges and war. Keep in mind the USA has engaged in significantly more wars than the National Socialists did and is responsible for far more "purges" than the National Socialists were. Of course, the National Socialists lost before their empire started so over the long-term, it's entirely 100% speculation.
It's quite arguable who instigated WWII. Did Russia or Ukraine start the Ukraine war? Putin claims it was the West and the West claims it was Putin. I tend to side with Putin and believe the West instigated it and the West instigated it much in the same manner as how the West instigated Hitler into war. If you want the full details though of why Hitler had to go to war, the short answer is that Hitler wanted to industrialize Germany which required excess food supply from rural people to support city people. Germany did not have enough food to support their growing city population because the West stopped trading with Germany because Germany stopped paying the reparations and interest on their debt which was arguably not something that was fair for them to be paying in the first place. So it really depends where you stand here. if the West traded food to Germany to sustain their industrial development, then Hitler wouldn't have felt forced into going to war to claim more agriculture land to boost his food supply for his industrialization. The Soviets had a similar issue but the Soviet solution was to kill all the rural Christians instead then steal their food. Less mouths to feed and free food.
Lastly, the only reason Hitler left ruin in his wake is because the West attacked him and caused ruin. The real villains of WWII are the Soviets, Britain and the Americans. France also but they were worthless anyhow. The allies are the bad guy not the good guys. Today you live under the Authoritarian Leftist Dictatorship of the West.