The argument they make is that the invasion doesn't actually replace the white people; just adds to them.
I find this a pointless thing to argue about.
Because it's not about our absolute numbers. It's about the quality of the culture that we live in.
To the extent that a leftist will have this argument with you, I think we shouldn't talk past each other. The invasion does actually suppress the white birthrate, because of competition for resources. And the browning of the population reduces the quality of life for everyone. This is theoretical, but if we actually let in masses of white people -- there are more than a few who want in -- I think it wouldn't be nearly as bad.
The crux of it seems to be that the open borders people don't understand what's going on. You propose a way to educate them. I also suggest that we could just stop listening to the uninformed. White, male landowners are already pretty based on immigration. Back in the day, we didn't need to house illegals in weird places to get the point across. Democracy as a decision making mechanism just didn't listen to the chronically-uninformed.
As fun as your proposal sounds, we can't have a government program to educate on every issue. If stupid people are voting, democracy is lost anyways. It is likely to be replaced some sort of authoritarian mechanism, because people will value safety over freedom when it comes down to it. We've seen that before.
For all I know, democracy is entirely untenable, but it seems like it really went sideways with the expansion of the franchise. I'd like to see us roll that back before we go straight into the government placing illegals in people's houses.
Simultaneously "not happening, it's a good thing and you deserve it".
The argument they make is that the invasion doesn't actually replace the white people; just adds to them.
I find this a pointless thing to argue about.
Because it's not about our absolute numbers. It's about the quality of the culture that we live in.
To the extent that a leftist will have this argument with you, I think we shouldn't talk past each other. The invasion does actually suppress the white birthrate, because of competition for resources. And the browning of the population reduces the quality of life for everyone. This is theoretical, but if we actually let in masses of white people -- there are more than a few who want in -- I think it wouldn't be nearly as bad.
The crux of it seems to be that the open borders people don't understand what's going on. You propose a way to educate them. I also suggest that we could just stop listening to the uninformed. White, male landowners are already pretty based on immigration. Back in the day, we didn't need to house illegals in weird places to get the point across. Democracy as a decision making mechanism just didn't listen to the chronically-uninformed.
As fun as your proposal sounds, we can't have a government program to educate on every issue. If stupid people are voting, democracy is lost anyways. It is likely to be replaced some sort of authoritarian mechanism, because people will value safety over freedom when it comes down to it. We've seen that before.
For all I know, democracy is entirely untenable, but it seems like it really went sideways with the expansion of the franchise. I'd like to see us roll that back before we go straight into the government placing illegals in people's houses.
Curtis Yarvan did a recent piece and mentioned this. Live in Johannesburg for a week.