I ask this because the other day my oldest brother who is a total normie (plus in his teen years he was busy with one lady after the next while in my teen years I was researching UFO cases, reading sci-fi and buying classic rock and RnB records) was telling me about The Boys and was shocked that I wasn't watching it. I told him that I have some of the comic book and they are fine but that at this point I am just so sick of deconstruction or subversion.
I have the the Watchmen comic by Alan Moore and his life views aside it is a great comic. The only problem is that it spawned to this day so many "what if super heroes were bad" or "dark and gritty side of super heroes" stories. My two worst cases of these modern trends are the Last Jedi because I think Rian Johnson is a typical hollywood douchebag who thinks you aren't smart if you don't appreciate his movies and I question his motivations because I don't think he would give a beloved female character the "Luke treatment". Another example would be Ayra killing the Night King in Game of Thrones because while I enjoy her character in the books I can't help but think that their motivation was girl power and to say "well everyone expected Jon to fight the Night King" is a terrible reason to not do it.
Some good examples off the top of my head are Yoda in Empire Strikes back because it was an interesting surprise to see a little green guy after hearing about a great warrior/Jedi master, but there was a lesson there. Also, in the first Ice and Fire book or Game of Thrones season 1 I didn't see Ned Stark being executed because I thought he would be the main character throughout. Granted there is a pretty sad lesson there about the consequences of doing the right thing and being honest.
What are your examples?
I don't recall him being incompetent in the newer ones. Goofy and foolish, yes, but he also manages to kick ass and be effective as well. Ash legitimately knows what's going on and can predict what needs to happen--but he's a blow-hard party animal weirdo too.
I watched only the first season and in it he was constantly shown up by his new Diverse cast, I can't recall a single good one-liner, and honestly can't even remember him doing anything cool. At all. In fact, near the end when he and the black detective chick suddenly have a love interest out of nowhere, I immediately guessed that the Ash involved was the evil, fake ash because I didn't think there would be any way that the writers would give the new, pathetic Ash even a moment where he wasn't being shit on. Then, at the end of the season, he chooses to run away as it is clear the world is going to shit and that there would be anywhere to run to.
Maybe the following seasons did him better, but I wasn't willing to watch any more after that.
I think the first episode, directed by Raimi, was the only good part. Aside from Ash accidentally reading from the book which is fucking retarded.
I did also like the use of Evil Ash. But yeah after ep 1 the show mostly shit.