This shit is scary. People don't know what's going to hit them.
(media.scored.co)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (165)
sorted by:
Okay. That doesn't address my point in any way. Positional motors for example, still have to be taught and calibrated in meat space, because even fractions of a millimeter can be disastrous in a factory setting.
I'm not talking product quality here either, I'm talking buildings burning down and production lines halted.
Having a pretty VR interface for some remote worker somewhere does nothing to change that.
I genuinely promise you that high resolution physics engines exist right now to simulate robots. You feed them movement code and they simulate the operations of the robot in extraordinary detail. This is used to test code without running a real robot manufacturing process.
Using software like this would give high quality feedback to train a Deep Learning Neural Network.
If someone isn't doing it today, they will be by the end of the year.
The "simulation" part doesn't matter. It won't help you actually use robotics to repair themselves in the real world.
I can't quite fathom the confusion of thinking that would cause you to make this comment.
It is exactly like pointing to the steam train and saying "Well, it doesn't do naval transport!."
So what?
If you can build a knowable robotics assembly cell. That is, a cell with a robot tool in it, for which the calibration, control systems, physical distances etc are known. Then you can put that information into a simulator and then use it to grade the responses of Deep Learning Neural Networks.
Yeah, some robotics tools will be better than others, and some will be more capable than others. You can simulate that too! Now you have the potential to test a million robotic work cells, and do it all before you spend your first dollar on physical robots. You can even optimize designing robots to build other, better robots and bootstrap a tool chain.
Suddenly assembling the parts of a robot bunny becomes a software problem. It is scalable and measurable. You can recruit computer network arrays to simulate the work and grade it, then give that feedback to the NN.
Now complex problems of robot manufacturing can be approached with exactly the same tools that is having Deep Learning Neural Networks paint like Rembrandt or write novels like Joke Rowling.
Look, it does not matter if you believe me or not. It is coming down the pipe. Just sit back and relax.
So you're trying to do naval transport, and handing me a blueprint of a steam train.
Except how you don't. Blah blah blah Neural Network, still non real nonsense. Absolutely relevant to jack shit. It cannot be used in the real world without actually doing the real world work. You can't get around that hurdle, anything else is just jerking off. It is not and never will be solely a "software problem" because at some point you actually have to cross the line into physically doing something.
So without fapping on about non real bullshit, answer the fuckin question already.
How do you propose to actually DO anything at all to create a robot capable of repairing itself in the real world, without a human doing said work physically?
Assuming our fake and gay economy doesn't implode by then. Hard to power the robots and simulations when there's no fucking electricity because the fascists
seizednationalized oil and gas companies (for "national security" reasons, of course).