The fan response to Netflix’s The Witcher was very diverse. From love to hate and everything in between. The aspect that was discussed more than others among fans was the writing and various writing decisions. Showrunner Lauren S. Hissrich offers a look into her practise of hiring writers for the show.
“When writing an adaptation, are the best writers always the ones most familiar with the world?”, she started. “Yes. And equally importantly, no.”
She continued: “Let me back up. When you write an adaptation, you have to be familiar with the original work. Yes. Of course. The writers and staff on The Witcher had to read all of the books, and had to appreciate/enjoy the genre. But I specifically didn’t seek out ten Sapkowski scholars.”
Earlier, Lauren offered a look into her other criteria for hiring The Witcher‘s writing staff.
“When hiring writers for The Witcher, there were several factors I looked at to make sure we were getting the best possible team. In no particular order:
A spectrum of writing experience: people who’d been at it for 20 years and those who were brand new. It’s part of my job to mentor the next generation of writers, just as I was once trained. But I also need people who know television structure and production inside and out.
A spectrum of life experience. This is where diversity comes in. A POC has different experiences than a white person; men different than women; straight different than gay. Add in immigrants, adoptees, parents, the list goes on. Varied life experiences make the show richer.
Black Panther was Jewish American wild fiction about Africa based on generally nothing, it's just creative.
The Witcher is Polish fiction about Europe based mostly about Western European mythologies and histories (only marginally Eastern European, especially after the first short stories, contrary to the popular meme), also some blatant plagiarism from a relatively obscure English fantasy author named Moorcock who doesn't care about it.
I just spent a few minutes searching for it to no avail, but I remember seeing a 4chan post around the time season 1 dropped that purported to be written by one of the token males on the production or writing team. He described one meeting where the lead producer went on an angry rant about how trump and right-wingers were “dickheads” and then the staff decided to make the Nilfgardians a stand-in for trump followers. And so, they designed the Nilfgardian armour thusly: https://i.redd.it/tkyqqxby1r131.jpg
The author of the post described how he was ignored when trying to bring some sanity to the discussion. I wonder if this DeMayo guy is the author of the 4chan post?
That's the ultimate goal of all of these subversive remakes. They don't care if the product is financially successful. It's like a suicide bomb on these cultural institutions, some of which have lasted generations.
Flashback 2020:
Don’t forget one writer saying that Black Panther and The Witcher were not the same for maintaining an ethnic mythos…
Black Panther was Jewish American wild fiction about Africa based on generally nothing, it's just creative.
The Witcher is Polish fiction about Europe based mostly about Western European mythologies and histories (only marginally Eastern European, especially after the first short stories, contrary to the popular meme), also some blatant plagiarism from a relatively obscure English fantasy author named Moorcock who doesn't care about it.
Well yeah, thems the things they're best at.
Got a link to this interview?
https://redanianintelligence.com/2020/06/08/the-witcher-showrunner-on-the-writing-staff-i-specifically-didnt-seek-out-ten-sapkowski-scholars/
I just spent a few minutes searching for it to no avail, but I remember seeing a 4chan post around the time season 1 dropped that purported to be written by one of the token males on the production or writing team. He described one meeting where the lead producer went on an angry rant about how trump and right-wingers were “dickheads” and then the staff decided to make the Nilfgardians a stand-in for trump followers. And so, they designed the Nilfgardian armour thusly: https://i.redd.it/tkyqqxby1r131.jpg
The author of the post described how he was ignored when trying to bring some sanity to the discussion. I wonder if this DeMayo guy is the author of the 4chan post?
I found a screenshot of it.
All part of the demoralization agenda. They want to destroy everything we love.
That's the ultimate goal of all of these subversive remakes. They don't care if the product is financially successful. It's like a suicide bomb on these cultural institutions, some of which have lasted generations.
"Why couldn't we have been working on another feminist hatred piece! That's why I went into this industry!" - Every woman in that room.
It was pretty clear from watching the show that the writers weren't fans of the source material.
Wow what a shocker
My Bacon number to the writing team happens to be 2 and that lines up with what I had heard too.