I just don't see that at all man. It's pretty much a settled issue on the right, that's why a lot of us roll our eyes at just how hard zionists are going on it, because the motive is so transparent. You may get people on the right downplaying the size of the issue when zionists go on about it, or bring up Israel or Jews as a counter argument. But I think you're overstating the sentiment of right wingers towards Islam, it's not about being pro Islam as it is being anti Zionist/Israel/Judaism. The only people I see buying into that dichotomy are low IQ zionist right wingers.

For example they all say Tucker is a Qatar shill and pro Islam etc and it's laughable. For most on the right Islam isn't an interesting conversation at this point because in the US it isn't the most pressing issue, there's no real debate among right wingers etc.

It's obviously an existential threat if you mass import them, it's obviously incompatible in the west when you get enough of them, Muhammed was a pedophile etc. If you polled Israel critical right wingers about deporting all Muslims it would have an extremely high approval rating, we're all immigration hawks. We just reject the dichotomy of you're with the Jews/Israel/ "The West" or you're with the Muslims