Does anyone think Tate is guilty of some kind of crime?

I'm honestly not familiar enough with things to know. Like you said, there's plenty pointing toward him not being a great person, but that's about it. Everything else seems like smears.

And I was just talking to someone today, pointing out that he's one of those people you're simply not allowed to support, like Trump, or Alex Jones.

My take? Tate's not a good dude. But most of that other shit is smears by people who hate him, hate us, hate Trump, hate conservatives, hate Americans, all that jazz. Doesn't make him good, but does mean it seems sensible to take a lot of the smears with a grain of salt.