Witcher channel asks for sign ins due to age so using the IGN vid atm, if anyone knows of a way to archive this or whatever please go for it.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWMu6JeT2g8
Some 4chan thoughts on the matter.
https://boards.4chan.org/vrpg/thread/3675650/witcher-4
c/Gaming thoughts on the matter.
https://communities.win/c/Gaming/p/19A0ojiz4R/witcher-4-ciri-the-girlboss/c
Turns out she did undergo the Trial of the Grasses
Is it from the books? Or the first 3 games?
Then it doesn't count. Shitty retcons to excuse shitting sequels should be dismissed for the shitshow they are.
Yeah, and she died for some players, so gg you dipshit. What other forced narratives are going to happen? Did Geralt end up with Yenn or Triss? Did he save Beauclair or not? What happened to
David BeckhamOlgierd?lolno, JFC these idiots don't even know their own bullshit. Ciri has been fighting with a sword for years, even just by the time she shows up in 3. There's a ruthless murderer/assassin in the books that had killed several witchers already that Ciri ends up being the one that kills him, it's where she gets her Cat medallion in the first place before the Crones take it in 3. She's already burned herself out magic wise, she's traveled to Earth, Cyberpunk, the homeworld of the Unicorns and Aen Elle, and done far, far more in the short time she's been alive than most do even just account for normal livespans, something she doesn't even have because of her heritage as a child of the Elder blood, descendant of Lara Dorren, and status as a Source.
Zero fucking surprise these vultures have no idea what they are talking about.
Geralt, nor any of the other remaining witchers, would ever have allowed Ciri to undergo that trial. I don't remember the exact number, but it kills about 70-90% of all the kids that undergo it. Geralt loves Ciri like a father. He simply would not have let her do it, would not teach her what ingredients were used, how to make the potions, or done it for her.
Furthermore, if I remember correctly, there are several story points, lines of dialogue, and quests in Kaer Morhen (the Witcher 3) that say the trial of grasses is no longer possible. The manuscripts detailing the knowledge are all gone. The apparatuses for doing the trial are in ruins. And Vesemir was the last remaining witcher who knew the ingredients, and he was killed in Witcher 3.
This is all lore shattering, character destroying bullshit for just another girlboss game.
I'm unaware of the book lore, is there even a single precedent for an adult to undergo the Trial? In the lore of the games, the only example we have of witchers' secrets being used on adults were the Salamandra mutant soldiers from Witcher 1. Oh hey, maybe I just wrote the lore for Ciri being a butterface now...! You're welcome CDP.
Intuitively it feels like the reason they take witchers as kids is because the trial only works on kids, when it works at all. Genetically altering an adult, who has already undergone all their physical development, doesn't sound like it would make the trial easier, instead it sounds impossible.
If witcher schools could witcherfy adults, even adults with magic capabilities, there should be no good explanation for witchers dying out.
EDIT: also, since it just occurred to me - are we supposed to celebrate the fact that she's sterile now ('And That's A Good Thing...!')? Or will they dodge that uncomfortable implication with convenient plot armour or strategic non-discussion?
WHY?
Because it's a product in the skinsuit of a beloved story, literally no other reason. No point torturing your head.
The MC has to be Ciri because of member berries, feminism, and the alternative being a white male in 2024. The MC in a Witcher game has to be a witcher or else people get mad plus half the lore and gameplay mechanics are gone, so she has to have done the Trial of Grasses. Any further fake explanation of 'why' is going to be totally post hoc, in fact consider it subject to constant internal revision right up until release.