Well it's nice he could get The Elon's attention, but that 1984 fellow is gonna be persona non grata'd next.
The quote is interesting. Out of context I suppose it could be seen as a call to violence today, but at the time before the Holocaust story became dominant, all that was being discussed publicly was extracting Judaism from Germany.
I was curious, and looked it up. He's a philosophizing weirdo who, among other things, seems to think that 'all ideas are truth,' or whatever. This should not be viewed as a summary, as there's a lot more there, and I barely skimmed it, but the argument seems to be that national socialism/state capitalism is good, because it's opposed to Judaism, but is also an imitation of Judaism, and Judaism is the superior world philosophy, and so shall win and subsume the Aryan/non-Jew. If you fight the Jew, you become the Jew, because Judaism is better and chosen by God. So a worldwide sweeping of Naziism would in fact turn the whole world into Jews
Like I said, it's some weird philosophical musings. It's also ridiculously structured; I've never seen someone make a statement as though it's fact and then say 'we'll address this later' as many times as he does. He also talks in circles, and often ends a paragraph with essentially the same sentence or idea he began it with. Sometimes even the very next sentence is essentially the same as the last. It's pretty painful.
As to the Hitler stuff, he says Hitler is the most genius antisemite since Balaam, who he in turn says was the greatest antisemite in history.
Since the days of Balaam, Hitler is the first anti-Semite that was great enough to adopt this method. But, like Balaam Hitler does not perceive that, if the Aryan nations endeavor to acquire the merits and virtues of the Jews, they will also become Jews, and then they will join the Jews. And so, as in the case of Balaam, Jehovah turns the curses of Hitler into a blessing. We shall presently see how the curses of Hitler turn into a blessing.
And, here, have some word salad:
In speaking of the economico-political world situation that faces the Jews and mankind generally, I spoke of fascism as comprehending nazism and communism, signifying the political form of state capitalism. But now that I come to speak of the biologico-cultural aspect of the world situation, I will speak of nazism. Nazism is economico-politically fascism, but nazism is more than fascism; in addition to being the political form of state capitalism, nazism is also anti-Semitism. The anti-Semitism of fascism is due to nazism.
Alrighty.
Anti-Semitism is as old as the Jews are. As soon as the Jews appeared on the historic stage, anti-Semitism appeared....
Anti-Semitism is the mortal dread of Judaism and the Jews. A religion does not fall from the sky, nor does it arise from historic or material conditions; a religion is the manifestation of the soul of a race or of a people; it manifests the destiny of the race or of the people. The destiny is intuitively perceived by the foremost of the race or of the people. And this is the reason why a race or a people rises and falls together with its religion. This means that the race or the people rises and falls with its soul. The Jews differ from all other races and peoples because of Judaism; Judaism differs from all other religions because of Jehovah; and Jehovah differs from all other gods. All other gods dwell in heaven. For this reason, all other religions are concerned about heaven, and they promise all reward in heaven after death. For this reason, all other religions negate the earth and the material world and are indifferent to the well-being and progress of mankind on this earth. But Jehovah comes down from heaven to dwell on this earth and to embody himself in mankind. For this reason, Judaism concerns itself only about this earth and promises all reward right here on this earth. The Kingdom of God is to be realized right here on this earth. The immortality which men are to enjoy, they will enjoy right here on this earth. God assumes his holiest name, Jehovah, only on this earth and when embodied in man. This is the reason why Jehovah promised to give this earth an eternal inheritance to those that will identify themselves with Jehovah. All that identify themselves with Jehovah are Jews, they are the children of Jehovah. This is the soul and essence of Judaism, and this is the soul of the Jews.
All through the past, the anti-Semites perceived intuitively, though vaguely, that the Jews will inherit this earth, and that all other races will either disappear altogether or they will become Jews and they will together with the Jews inherit this earth. This was the mortal dread of the anti-Semites. It was the dread that is felt by one who faces the yawning mouth of the serpent who is about to swallow him. Judaism appeared to the anti-Semites as a serpent that is about to swallow them. It was not only the dread of death but worse still, it was the dread of being swallowed by the serpent Judaism and be turned into Jews. Every individual being endeavors to persevere in its being. And this is also true of man. Man wants to exist forever, but he wants to exist as he is. For an anti-Semite to be converted into a Jew is worse than death. This seemed to the anti-Semites as being converted into an inferior being, since they regarded the Jews as being inferior to themselves. This was and is the mortal dread of the anti-Semites.
It's, uh, some weird stuff.
My program is just a program for a supreme struggle against the enemies of the Jews, it is a program for a heroic struggle against barbarity and inhumanity. It is not a question, whether the Jews should struggle; it is a question, how the Jews should struggle? The method of struggle pursued until now was both irrational and ineffective, and only aggravated the situation for the Jews...
The question before us is this: which course is rational and effective, to continue a futile and hopeless fight against the nazis and the fascists, simply because we once stupidly started this fight; or to recognize the futility and stupidity of this fight, and to endeavor to make peace with the nazis and the fascists? Is this a novel question?
...Later the Allied Powers similarly imposed upon the Germans a humiliating and cruel peace treaty. Well, where is that treaty now ? Who is now the master in Europe, France and England, or Germany? Why should not the Jews learn from history? It takes a great man, like Lenin, to accept a humiliating defeat, in order that out of the defeat to create a triumphant victory.
...But my program calls for just this: to overcome the false pride and stupid vanity that dictated the policy of the Jews until now. Let the Jews come out from their nursery, and let them face the reality and act rationally. Six years passed since the Jews outside of Germany declared war against Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy. The Jews will never admit that the recent pogroms had much to do with their stupid boycott. If, instead of wasting valuable time on a futile and hopeless struggle, the Jews had used these years for constructive work to help the Jews in distress, infinitely more good would have been accomplished....
But suppose that the Jews changed their attitude towards the nazis and the fascists; suppose that the Jews made an honest and sincere attempt to make peace with the nazis and the fascists; and suppose that, notwithstanding all this, the nazis and the fascists will not change their attitude towards the Jews; suppose that the nazis and the fascists will persist in their determination to destroy the Jews—what will the Jews accomplish? The Jews will accomplish a moral and historic victory over the nazis and the fascists. The Jews will justify themselves before mankind, before posterity and before history. We must not forget this...And before that humanity the Jews will justify themselves, if they themselves act rationally and morally. The Jews can afford to be magnanimous and just even to the nazis and the fascists. Now that the democratic countries are preparing themselves for a struggle with the fascist countries, now is the proper time for the Jews to bring to mankind the message of peace. It is not for the Jews to foment strife and to inflame the passions for war. But all this requires a strength of mind and a moral virtue which infinitely transcend the pretended virtue of fighting a stupid and hopeless fight. Hence it will not lie in the mouth of any one to say that my program is a defeatist program; on the contrary, my program is a program of supreme effort and heroic struggle, because it is a struggle against ourselves, against our own false pride and vanity. Are the Jews ready to take up this heroic struggle ? If so, they will overcome their enemies; the Jews will overcome their enemies by converting them into friends.
I'm not surprised. He literally asserted that Hitler's solution to exterminating jews was a good action.
I'm not going to stand here and defend a Socialist's jew-hating propaganda when they'd gladly silence and put a bullet in me, despite the fact that I'm still not a jew.
Elon claims that it was this tweet that got him banned. https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1810589645471645698
Well it's nice he could get The Elon's attention, but that 1984 fellow is gonna be persona non grata'd next.
The quote is interesting. Out of context I suppose it could be seen as a call to violence today, but at the time before the Holocaust story became dominant, all that was being discussed publicly was extracting Judaism from Germany.
I was curious, and looked it up. He's a philosophizing weirdo who, among other things, seems to think that 'all ideas are truth,' or whatever. This should not be viewed as a summary, as there's a lot more there, and I barely skimmed it, but the argument seems to be that national socialism/state capitalism is good, because it's opposed to Judaism, but is also an imitation of Judaism, and Judaism is the superior world philosophy, and so shall win and subsume the Aryan/non-Jew. If you fight the Jew, you become the Jew, because Judaism is better and chosen by God. So a worldwide sweeping of Naziism would in fact turn the whole world into Jews
Like I said, it's some weird philosophical musings. It's also ridiculously structured; I've never seen someone make a statement as though it's fact and then say 'we'll address this later' as many times as he does. He also talks in circles, and often ends a paragraph with essentially the same sentence or idea he began it with. Sometimes even the very next sentence is essentially the same as the last. It's pretty painful.
As to the Hitler stuff, he says Hitler is the most genius antisemite since Balaam, who he in turn says was the greatest antisemite in history.
And, here, have some word salad:
Alrighty.
It's, uh, some weird stuff.
Pretty tame besides the reference to funny mustache man that makes them REEE.
I'm not surprised. He literally asserted that Hitler's solution to exterminating jews was a good action.
I'm not going to stand here and defend a Socialist's jew-hating propaganda when they'd gladly silence and put a bullet in me, despite the fact that I'm still not a jew.