It's only contradictory if you want it to be contradictory. It doesn't need to hold any logical congruency to any set of morals. It just needs to do what is in people's best interests.
And your compromise is better than nothing but why would I start there in a negotiation when I can start all the way over where I was before? Think of the men who want children that the woman murders with abortion, omg... terrible. We need to look out for these men. If a woman aborts a child against the man's wishes, that's murder. But I'd be fine if all we accomplished is where you're willing to compromise.
Men's rights fails for one simple reason. Lack of power. That is all.
I starting writing a long answer to explain this to you, because I think you are sincere, but I ended up deleting it because it was getting unwieldy. In short, what you are proposing is simply unrealistic considering how societies and human morality function, biologically and "spiritually". Unless you can create a successful cult to push your ideas, changes to moral frameworks occur over generations. I hope you already understand this and you are just venting a hypothetical.
It's only contradictory if you want it to be contradictory. It doesn't need to hold any logical congruency to any set of morals. It just needs to do what is in people's best interests.
And your compromise is better than nothing but why would I start there in a negotiation when I can start all the way over where I was before? Think of the men who want children that the woman murders with abortion, omg... terrible. We need to look out for these men. If a woman aborts a child against the man's wishes, that's murder. But I'd be fine if all we accomplished is where you're willing to compromise.
Men's rights fails for one simple reason. Lack of power. That is all.
I starting writing a long answer to explain this to you, because I think you are sincere, but I ended up deleting it because it was getting unwieldy. In short, what you are proposing is simply unrealistic considering how societies and human morality function, biologically and "spiritually". Unless you can create a successful cult to push your ideas, changes to moral frameworks occur over generations. I hope you already understand this and you are just venting a hypothetical.