The Great Reset mastermind suggests risk assessment brain scans to travel
(www.zerohedge.com)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (123)
sorted by:
No. No one else go around calling themselves "gods chosen ones" meant to lead the "goyim" and that "goyim" is considered "beast" according to the Talmud
There was resistance to it because people doubted their lineage. But at the end of the day they still have the "right of return" that Europeans do not and Ashkenazi still identify with them more sooner than they identify with white European ,and they do not consider themselves white Europeans.
First Germany doesn't do it anymore, Second "Other countries do it too" does not debunk my point that the fact that the right of return law only applies to Ashkenazi Jews for being Jews, but does not apply to European, is the point, which is that they are different tribes.
Please speak proper English i have no idea what you are trying to say here. The only point i made is that Ashkenazi don't see themselves as European whites.
Well if you say that you are just showing your true colours now aren't you? And you ask why people mention the hatred against Europeans? There is a Jewish tribe but no European tribe? And i never said "Ashkenazi is a tribe" i said its a subset of the Jewish tribe.
Yes you can when you notice the reoccurring patterns and behaviors and how they talk about another demographic constantly .(And thanks for admitting they are different demographics)
1.) Yes. It's not my fault you don't know tribal history.
2.) Again, you're just making assertions based off of your own personal definitions of how the groups are defined.
3.) Germany stopped doing it as of the 2000's. My counter to your point is that your point isn't relevant, because it's not something unique to Jews. Your point doesn't make sense one way or another. Europe is not a tribe. Jews can recognize that Jews are also European. It is not either-or. Also, the Right of Return exists for many different types of Jews, not just Ashkenazi.
4.) You are using abstractions that you define, to speak on behave of masses of individuals. Y
5.) There is no European tribe because there has never been a European tribe. A tribe is a smaller and more homogeneous population category than a nation. There is no nation of Europeans because they are far too different. The continent of Europe is filled with utterly dissimilar people's who do not even have a common language. The unifying feature of Europeans, is that they live in Europe. Europe is comprised of many nations of peoples, many of whom have ancient grievances with one another. Those nations may be comprised of tribes, but they are more closely affiliated with class and clan. Are family clan's tribes? Maybe, but that seems like a stretch.
5-b.) So what of Jews? Jews are not a tribe. Hell, the Jews even cite that they comprise "the tribes of Israel". That is a recognition that even in their origin, they were not one tribe. They were multiple tribes, unified by a religion. You could call the Jews of that time period a nation, or proto-nation. "Jew" is an amalgamation of multiple tribes. Jews would be closer to a nation, than a tribe. However, Judaism is the unifying religion for Jews, and it has many different splits, divisions, and factions. The religion (particularly modern or reformist interpretations) supports a level of integration and assimilation that make it hard to even hold the "nation" title. Religions are not Nations. Nations are not Tribes. Tribes are not Clans. The Jewish struggle with Jewish identity might be one of the most exhaustively documented ideological conflicts that any people have ever had. But you keep treating them as if this is some homogeneous group that solved this question over 2,000 years ago. They didn't.
6.) You realize you can be part of more than one demographic, right? Actually, no, you probably don't given that you seem to be a racialist and you keep harping on the idea that Europeans and Jewry are purely separate and 'never the two shall meet'. This makes your comment about Ethiopian Jews seem especially disingenuous, given that you should be making the exact same argument that some Jews in Israel argue: "They're not Jews, they're Africans". Yet, you pointed out that Ethiopian Jews exist, but can't seem to tolerate the idea that European Jews also exist. You're taking up positions based on what you think might hurt your strawman's argument.
You are literally just trying to play a whole lot of mental gymnastics and semantics to try to defend your BS lies. I never said the right of return only applies to Ashkenazi i said the opposite of that and i also said that the fact that it doesn't apply to European just shows they are two different things.
.Also no shared European identity or lineage? Most Europeans would beg to differ ( And Jews are Semitic not European also Jews themselves have called Jews as a whole "a tribe" and a "tribe" is a people that follow a shared history, lineage and identity, which guess what? Ashkenazi and European do not.) . So i'll cut to the chase, end of the day, Ashkenazis are Semitic and identify as such (but keep trying to pretend that a Semitic group is "European" like Danish, or English are) and Ashkenazis themselves do not identify with Europeans , and when they pretend to its usually to attack or insult Europeans.
They do not identify with Europeans among themselves (and they say that). They follow the Semitic lineage first and foremost , being mixed does not change what they identify with which is being Semitic or Jewish first and foremost. .
The loyalties and identity is not there. And they do not identify with the demographic that they call "goyim" and "beasts" in their own Talmud (which you still have not addressed btw)
You can keep trying to pretend and lie and make all sorts of excuses in the world but we both know the truth . Stop lying and pretending.
Why would you think that the current Israeli government policy speaks for all Jews? That's ridiculous. Oh right, you probably have a National Socialist / Fascist perspective. The State is The People and The People are The State.
Most Europeans would agree. Meet some, try talking to them, and discover that they don't all speak English because they are wildly different people, with different cultures, values, philosophies, histories, experiences, political systems, religions, etc, etc.
Again, you're ignoring the fact that Semites and Europeans interbred. Yes, European Jews are a thing by both marriage, conversion, and de-conversion.
I never said that.
You're asserting that out of nothing.
So that identity is a social construct, is it? That would make it even easier to identify European Jews.
Most Europeans don't have "loyalties" to Europe. They have their own individual nations of people, and states that they may be loyal to. Pan-Europeanism is as ridiculous as Pan-Africanism.
Why should I address it? Holy Books say stupid shit sometimes. What matters is whether or not anyone cares about internalizing that portion of scripture. I don't think your prepared to recognize the nuance between Secular Jews, Ethnic Jews, Religious Jews, Israeli Jews, and other such insular division among Jews to actually understand that just because the Talmud says a thing, it doesn't mean every Jew utterly internalizes that thing.
These aren't excuses, their failures in your own reductive narrative.
You seriously are trying to say "its just the state"? Are you just arguing for the sake of arguing now? Trying to pretend its "just the state" as if you are trying to pretend that any Jew would approve of having Israel's right of return laws include Europeans or any other non-Jew? Are you just trying to troll?
Second this whole arguement from the beginning was you trying to pretend that there isn't a prevalent hatred against Europeans from jews, because "muh ashkenazis are european " cAuSe mIxINg and i have debunked that and you have tried to pretend that ashkenazis have no hate against Europeans and that a semitic group is somehow european when they are no where near that and they do not even identify as such and follow a different lineage, history and identity and non stop attack against europeans . They will only say they are when its convenient to them but will say they are not when its not. They will say they are especially when they feel like attacking Europeans with "muh fellow white people stop oppressing others" comments.
( Also if they truly are against the whole passage about "goyims and beasts" they would be openly condemning it but i never hear of them doing so . And do not pretend that a lot dont take it to heart ) .
. And you try to gaslight in to completely different topics altogether just to try to push a lie.. (but of course right?)
But if you still want to argue about it i'll send these to you. Straight from the horses mouth
https://archive.is/DkDDu,
https://archive.is/yZvgM
Comments from Ashkenazis :
"mult-generational Jews are not white people. We are not white people. Call me anything but a "white person" .... Hallelujah ..."
" I look "white" but always check "other" on forms. I am proud of what Jews contributed to humanity. However, I feel that our connection to Europe is a tragic incident in history. We are an old race. Why not be proud of it? What is so great about being European?"
"i dont see myself as white,although i was born in the u.k,my heritage is Askenazi "Lewin" and "Baker",are my family names,i agree that by deeming yourself as a white european,instead of a middle eastern diaspora jew,you are watering down your TRUE indentity,and denying your heritage. .....Am Yisrael Chai..John "Yoni"Andrews,Tipton,U.K"
But if you want to carry on lying, pretending , gas lighting and arguing for the sake of arguing to get the last word, then go on right ahead , not interested with talking to you anymore