Remove all the specific labels about Christians or atheists and nothing was said. JP was pushing back on small assumptions and waiting for the atheist to make his point, which I'm guessing had to do with The Mary Question. Instead of actually making that point, he quibbled about the specific labels you mentioned. And that's all that happened.

Remove all the specific labels about Christians or atheists and nothing was said. He was pushing back on small assumptions and waiting for the atheist to make his ultimate point, which I'm guessing had to do with The Mary Question. Instead of actually making that point, he quibbled about the specific labels you mentioned. And that's all that happened.