The early liberal response is startling. They're admitting that JD Vance really got to them. Vance wasn't cutting too many throats after half-time, but he seems to have genuinely got to them with grace and vibes.

I think they are really shook.

Robert Barnes is saying that Vance came in specifically to target undecided, working class, younger, women to move Trump, and I think he actually got them.

The early liberal response is startling. They're admitting that JD Vance really got to them. Vance wasn't cutting too many throats after half-time, but he seems to have genuinely got to them with grace and vibes.

I think they are really shook.