Win / KotakuInAction2
KotakuInAction2
Sign In
DEFAULT COMMUNITIES All General AskWin Funny Technology Animals Sports Gaming DIY Health Positive Privacy
Reason: None provided.

I 100% agree with Franklin but here is the issue, if only good people are capable of freedom because resumable good people won't use their freedom to commit evil, what good is freedom then? If you will only use your freedom to be good then you have no use for freedom because your actions are already restricted by your virtue.

There's a massive problem you didn't identify: good people don't always know what is good. This is where freedom of expression, through inquiry and discussion, has corrected a massive catalog of errors that would have destroyed the US otherwise.

Free expression, through the power of discovery, has also guaranteed the supremacy of the US, which is taken for granted.

Franklin's quote is absolutely correct, but it's descriptive, not prescriptive. You are advocating for things we "should" do, but that word is premised on the virtue that we would lack. In fact once the virtue is gone, all that remains is corruption and deterministic natural selection. You would be better off trying to secure your personal future instead of worrying about dying in the workings of an amoral system.

1 year ago
1 score
Reason: Original

I 100% agree with Franklin but here is the issue, if only good people are capable of freedom because resumable good people won't use their freedom to commit evil, what good is freedom then? If you will only use your freedom to be good then you have no use for freedom because your actions are already restricted by your virtue.

There's a massive problem you didn't identify: good people don't always know what is good. This is where freedom of expression, through inquiry and discovery, has corrected a massive catalog of errors that would have destroyed the US otherwise.

Franklin's quote is absolutely correct, but it's descriptive, not prescriptive. You are advocating for things we "should" do, but that word is premised on the virtue that we would lack. In fact once the virtue is gone, all that remains is corruption and deterministic natural selection. You would be better off trying to secure your personal future instead of worrying about dying in the workings of an amoral system.

1 year ago
1 score