But, he assured me, it was otherwise for “promise.” I was skeptical. How about “obligation?” We both had the same dictionary (English-Zulu, Zulu-English Dictionary, published by Witwatersrand University Press in 1958), and looked it up. The Zulu entry means “as if to bind one’s feet.” He said that was not indigenous but was added by the compilers. But if Zulu didn’t have the concept of obligation, how could it have the concept of a promise, since a promise is simply the oral undertaking of an obligation? I was interested in this, I said, because Africans often failed to keep promises and never apologized — as if this didn’t warrant an apology.
A light bulb seemed to go on in his mind. Yes, he said; in fact, the Zulu word for promise — isithembiso — is not the correct word. When a black person “promises” he means “maybe I will and maybe I won’t.” But, I said, this makes nonsense of promising, the very purpose of which is to bind one to a course of action. When one is not sure he can do something he may say, “I will try but I can’t promise.” He said he’d heard whites say that and had never understood it till now. As a young Romanian friend so aptly summed it up, when a black person “promises” he means “I’ll try.”
Make of it what you will. CPT is a real thing, though.
This is a perfect example of Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis. In all my Linguistics classes that deal with Sociolinguistics or language processing, there were no good examples. They were avoiding good ones like this one.
https://www.amren.com/archives/back-issues/february-2009/
Make of it what you will. CPT is a real thing, though.
This is a perfect example of Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis. In all my Linguistics classes that deal with Sociolinguistics or language processing, there were no good examples. They were avoiding good ones like this one.
I hadn't heard the name for it before. It looks like I can thank Chomsky for that. Thanks for the info.
It's actually from traditional linguistics, far before Chomsky. Chomsky contributed a lot to the science, but it existed long before him.
Yeah, I'm no linguist. Just a quick check shows that Chomsky is largely credited with discrediting linguistic relativity.
We can link to AmRen on this site? Based.