In a completely abstract theory Yaron is hypothetically correct. You know, if you played HOI4 or something. But reality is different.
However, America is an "Anglo In The Woods" 17th century English, Protestant, Lockean Liberal ideological experiment that wasn't even properly replicated across the English channel in France, despite people like Thomas Jefferson trying to help.
Ideas are not fully interchangeable because they are extensions of the people they emerge from. Even America before the Hart-Cellar Act was not the America it was in 1775.
If you wish for a nation to continue (let alone it's values), not only must the people be continued, but the traditions of those people must be preserved, and any new commers must be assimilated into that nation.
In theory, you could potentially have an America that wasn't white. But the time it would take to do that would either be so long that population would be white as well, or the assimilation of the foreigner would be so complete they wouldn't be able to tell the difference between themselves and the domestic population, which means they would probably think of themselves as White.
Albania is a White Shithole country. Being shitheads is what makes places shitholes. This is actually what "Broken Windows Policing" is intended to stop: don't allow for places to attract degenerate behavior by allowing the culture to degrade.
There is zero evidence that black and brown people are capable of upholding American ideals when they're the majority in a country. There is evidence that white people can.
Saying "in theory black/brown people could" is as worthless as saying in theory a pack of elephants could build a helicopter.
In a completely abstract theory Yaron is hypothetically correct. You know, if you played HOI4 or something. But reality is different.
However, America is an "Anglo In The Woods" 17th century English, Protestant, Lockean Liberal ideological experiment that wasn't even properly replicated across the English channel in France, despite people like Thomas Jefferson trying to help.
Ideas are not fully interchangeable because they are extensions of the people they emerge from. Even America before the Hart-Cellar Act was not the America it was in 1775.
If you wish for a nation to continue (let alone it's values), not only must the people be continued, but the traditions of those people must be preserved, and any new commers must be assimilated into that nation.
In theory, you could potentially have an America that wasn't white. But the time it would take to do that would either be so long that population would be white as well, or the assimilation of the foreigner would be so complete they wouldn't be able to tell the difference between themselves and the domestic population, which means they would probably think of themselves as White.
In theory my ass. Every black and brown majority country is a shit hole.
Albania is a White Shithole country. Being shitheads is what makes places shitholes. This is actually what "Broken Windows Policing" is intended to stop: don't allow for places to attract degenerate behavior by allowing the culture to degrade.
Albania has nothing to do with my point.
There is zero evidence that black and brown people are capable of upholding American ideals when they're the majority in a country. There is evidence that white people can.
Saying "in theory black/brown people could" is as worthless as saying in theory a pack of elephants could build a helicopter.
Is the Elephant Helicopter building near the Monkeys writing Shakespeare building?