How is it lying that students did it? You yourself wrote that the students asked for a list from the ministry. So it was an event primarliy organised by the students. OP did not state National Socialists weren't involved in that event. At least not in this post.
But that students burned "left wing" books is an oversimplification and depending on the intentions either ignorant or dishonest. On that point I agree with you.
It was organized by the National Socialists who tasked their National Socialist student members and societies to ask a National Socialist librarian for a blacklist, who then received a list from the National Socialist government.
Being a liar, no different from OP, you are trying to obfuscate the fact that National Socialists, including the government, were explicitly involved in every aspect of the event. The same way that modern socialists pretend that "Palestinian Protests" are purely grass-roots outrage of the student population, and not a major propaganda effort by Leftist organizations operating at every level.
It's your dishonesty that makes you and OP a liar.
Who is obfuscating the fact that those students were National Socialists? No one.
But there is a difference between an event organised/ordered by the government/party leadership from beginning to end and party members or people affiliated or sympathetic towards an ideology organising it from their own accord. Students aren't exactly known for not being politically outspoken.
Being a liar, no different from OP, you are trying to obfuscate the fact that National Socialists, including the government, were explicitly involved in every aspect of the event.
Yes, I am definitely trying to obfuscate the fact that the NSDAP government banned those books in the first place. :')
The same way that modern socialists pretend that "Palestinian Protests" are purely grass-roots outrage of the student population, and not a major propaganda effort by Leftist organizations operating at every level.
Considering that the absolute majority of the student population and student organisations are leftist, it's not exactly surprising.
But there is a difference between an event organised/ordered by the government/party leadership from beginning to end and party members or people affiliated or sympathetic towards an ideology organising it from their own accord. Students aren't exactly known for not being politically outspoken.
Yes, and it's the former. That's the obfuscation you are engaging in. It's the same way that Kristallnacht was directly ordered by the party, which then claimed it was a just a popular reaction.
Considering that the absolute majority of the student population and student organisations are leftist, it's not exactly surprising.
Yes, and it's the former. That's the obfuscation you are engaging in. It's the same way that Kristallnacht was directly ordered by the party, which then claimed it was a just a popular reaction.
Probably slightly more nuanced than that but I'll leave you be.
How is it lying that students did it? You yourself wrote that the students asked for a list from the ministry. So it was an event primarliy organised by the students. OP did not state National Socialists weren't involved in that event. At least not in this post.
But that students burned "left wing" books is an oversimplification and depending on the intentions either ignorant or dishonest. On that point I agree with you.
It was organized by the National Socialists who tasked their National Socialist student members and societies to ask a National Socialist librarian for a blacklist, who then received a list from the National Socialist government.
Being a liar, no different from OP, you are trying to obfuscate the fact that National Socialists, including the government, were explicitly involved in every aspect of the event. The same way that modern socialists pretend that "Palestinian Protests" are purely grass-roots outrage of the student population, and not a major propaganda effort by Leftist organizations operating at every level.
It's your dishonesty that makes you and OP a liar.
Who is obfuscating the fact that those students were National Socialists? No one.
But there is a difference between an event organised/ordered by the government/party leadership from beginning to end and party members or people affiliated or sympathetic towards an ideology organising it from their own accord. Students aren't exactly known for not being politically outspoken.
Yes, I am definitely trying to obfuscate the fact that the NSDAP government banned those books in the first place. :')
Considering that the absolute majority of the student population and student organisations are leftist, it's not exactly surprising.
Yes, and it's the former. That's the obfuscation you are engaging in. It's the same way that Kristallnacht was directly ordered by the party, which then claimed it was a just a popular reaction.
Yes, that's why they went around burning books.
Probably slightly more nuanced than that but I'll leave you be.
Guess everyone involved in WW2 was leftist then.