If trannies, blacks, and women all gained a disproportionate amount of power and influence, would it be social justice to point that out and say something fishy is going on?
That begs the question of what is a 'disproportionate' amount of power and influence.
If blacks, troons, etc. get power on account of being black or troons, then that is wrong for that reason. (Also because troons should not be allowed to be lunatics in public, but that is a different matter.)
But imagine say blacks completely turning themselves around, working very hard, avoiding crime, etc. and as a result becoming so successful that they are overrepresented in powerful and influential positions. That may be disproportionate, but it is not unwarranted.
On the other hand, if incompetent blacks are given pilot jobs, or powerful/influential positions because of the color of their skin, then that is unwarranted, and therefore wrong.
Yeah, I agree with that. The influence some jews have may not always be warranted either, but it's harder to prove that, especially when you're not allowed to talk about it.
"There are too many Jews in highly-paid professions."
"Jews monopolize everything to the detriment of others."
"Jews have too much power and influence."
If you just replaced the word "Jews" with "Whites" then you would magically change from being anti-semitic to anti-racist.
Correct. Anti-semitism is just social justice for the ultra-right.
If trannies, blacks, and women all gained a disproportionate amount of power and influence, would it be social justice to point that out and say something fishy is going on?
That begs the question of what is a 'disproportionate' amount of power and influence.
If blacks, troons, etc. get power on account of being black or troons, then that is wrong for that reason. (Also because troons should not be allowed to be lunatics in public, but that is a different matter.)
But imagine say blacks completely turning themselves around, working very hard, avoiding crime, etc. and as a result becoming so successful that they are overrepresented in powerful and influential positions. That may be disproportionate, but it is not unwarranted.
On the other hand, if incompetent blacks are given pilot jobs, or powerful/influential positions because of the color of their skin, then that is unwarranted, and therefore wrong.
Yeah, I agree with that. The influence some jews have may not always be warranted either, but it's harder to prove that, especially when you're not allowed to talk about it.