Degenerate modern definition of "trans person" means jack shit.
I don't quite recall which post wano chapter was it but I do remember some panels where Yamato wanted to join SH and Luffy flat out said to her that he doesn't want a faker/poser on his crew to which she just nod and accept.
Her "transness" is nothing more than her fanboyism toward Oden and the manga doesnt even try to hide it.
People can take their interpretations and shove them up where sunshine does not reach.
Explain the bath scene. I keep coming back to this, because this is flat out an example where there is a clear demarcation between whether she considers herself a man or a woman. Her words were that she couldn't go in the women's bath, "because there is no mixed bathing in the castle". So she went in the men's bath.
If other people's interpretations don't matter, and only yours does, then explain that one.
Because it's a Japanese work made by a japanese man with japanese mentality behind it.
In Japan, there's this thing called honne tatamae. It's a complex phenomenon that can be roughly described as keeping your opinions to yourself in order to not start a scene. It's sort of like political correctness except not pathological and has limit to it.
Put two and two together and you can figure out that the main cast is putting up with Yamato's antics because they don't want to cause a scene, especially since most of them are recuperating from a death battle and they're still technically outside invaders.
But when Yamato tries to push her shit on Luffy's ship, on his turf, that's when he doesn't need to put up a front anymore and tells Yamato straight up to cut with her bullshit.
This is what you get when you try to project western sensibilities on a eastern cultural product.
No. One Piece is not a international product and Oda certainly doesn't take hints from west on how to push his series. If that were not the case then Ivankov wouldn't be the joke he is.
Japanese mentality is delightfully stuck few decades behind the west and thank god for that.
Mate, no.
Yamato is as much pandering to troons as Ivankov is, that is not at all.
still, anime gender bending is a very easy access for troon entryism
Degenerate modern definition of "trans person" means jack shit.
I don't quite recall which post wano chapter was it but I do remember some panels where Yamato wanted to join SH and Luffy flat out said to her that he doesn't want a faker/poser on his crew to which she just nod and accept.
Her "transness" is nothing more than her fanboyism toward Oden and the manga doesnt even try to hide it.
People can take their interpretations and shove them up where sunshine does not reach.
Explain the bath scene. I keep coming back to this, because this is flat out an example where there is a clear demarcation between whether she considers herself a man or a woman. Her words were that she couldn't go in the women's bath, "because there is no mixed bathing in the castle". So she went in the men's bath.
If other people's interpretations don't matter, and only yours does, then explain that one.
Because it's a Japanese work made by a japanese man with japanese mentality behind it.
In Japan, there's this thing called honne tatamae. It's a complex phenomenon that can be roughly described as keeping your opinions to yourself in order to not start a scene. It's sort of like political correctness except not pathological and has limit to it.
Put two and two together and you can figure out that the main cast is putting up with Yamato's antics because they don't want to cause a scene, especially since most of them are recuperating from a death battle and they're still technically outside invaders.
But when Yamato tries to push her shit on Luffy's ship, on his turf, that's when he doesn't need to put up a front anymore and tells Yamato straight up to cut with her bullshit.
This is what you get when you try to project western sensibilities on a eastern cultural product.
No. One Piece is not a international product and Oda certainly doesn't take hints from west on how to push his series. If that were not the case then Ivankov wouldn't be the joke he is.
Japanese mentality is delightfully stuck few decades behind the west and thank god for that.