There has been no natural progression or actual improvement in the actual structure , art , quality, style etc. since marxists have taken over. It has been stagnant for a long time similar to western art and music in general. What do you think the american comic book industry could improve(outside of the obvious getting rid of woke stuff)?
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (36)
sorted by:
While I enjoy variety in any art, I don't think capeshit is even a critical problem in and of itself: two of the most popular manga to have come out in recent years are One-Punch Man and My Hero Academia, both of which are explicitly inspired by and feature classic Western-style superheroes doing superhero things (OPM's a parody, MHA plays it more seriously). They've both sold like hotcakes, I think MHA sold like 5 million copies last year while the most popular Western comics are lucky to break 300,000 and it's 'only' the 6th best-selling manga around, and they're equally beloved by Western and Japanese audiences alike.
There's clearly still demand for that stuff, it's just that nobody (quite justifiably) wants androgynous-melted-wax-figure Carol Danvers or Starfire's ridiculous self-insert daughter.
I have nothing against superheroes as a concept. One of my favourite anime is Tiger & Bunny, which deals with how people handle double identities, the commercialization of heroes, turning a noble pursuit into something fake, etc..
But yeah, Tiger & Bunny, MHA and OPM understand that to be a superhero you have to be super and heroic. I don't want superheroes to make me feel good about myself. SJW types don't understand the concept of a superhero. I want them to be amazing. No, not pudgy, neurotic losers.
Of course they can have flaws and such, but why would you call it a superhero when it's virtually identical to some bitchy librarian you can meet anywhere?
Superheroes can have flaws, "kryptonite" is practically a commonplace term for "a significant weakness". They can have weak points, flaws, they can make errors. But I must draw upon Anime to make a point. Specifically, Fate/ZERO. On the speech Iskander makes on the concept of being a King.
This applies to Heroes in general. A Hero isn't someone paid to save people. A Hero isn't even someone who saves people out of the goodness of their heart when presented with the opportunity to do so. A Hero is a Greater Person. Not a great person, greater. They are defined from tabula rasa as "more than".
Superman is Faster than a speeding bullet, stronger than a locomotive. But morally, too, he is gooder. By definition, a Hero cannot be reached. They embody what the feminists call "unrealistic portrayal" of humans. The most we can do is aspire to approach them. Villains, too, are Greater Persons. More evil, more cunning, even in some cases more petty than any human could aspire to, showcasing the worst, something to shy from.
That is the baseline of a Greater Person, they are beyond us in some unreachable way, but which either draws or repels us in that aspect. Real World Examples: If you say "I want to be like Nikola Tesla", you probably mean "I want to be creative, insightful, and intelligent", not "I want to be a dying-young virgin with only feral pigeons for friends". And on villainy, if you don't want to be like Hitler, you're probably thinking of the systematic murder of millions, not his belief that recycling is important for long-term societal stability. (At least, I hope you aren't viciously throwing a coke can into a compost bin with a knowing smile that you won't support Hitler's recycling ideals, but are fine with the other one.) In writing, likewise, there is infinite room for creativity in those secondary aspects and building the character, but line one of their description should be that Greater aspect that one must wish to approach, or fear.
But this is antithesis to modern western writing, where everyone must be "human". They focus on the flaws and lesser aspects. No one wants to read a story about Batman's struggles with changes to the tax code. He obviously deals with them, it's implicitly known by all of us, but no one cares, it's not his Greater aspect: World's Greatest Detective.