I'll give Bioshock credit for accurately depicting how their paradise would always be doomed, and Fontaine just supplied the largest blow faster. That place was falling apart at the seams because they all wanted to be the elite puppetmasters and forgot they still needed puppets for that. And by treating what puppets they had like literal garbage, they all got fucking killed by a bunch of lower class workers hopped up on the drugs they gave them.

Because the majority of the splicers aren't the "captains of industry" Ryan wanted, they are the dockworkers, failed actresses, poor doctors and other losers. I think only the Snobby Lady model isn't some sort of failed fool.

So even if we go with the its his "Jewish Paradise" idea, its still absolutely destroyed by the hubris of very common Jewish mistakes that any of us goys could tell would happen.