They're not using logic in your other examples either. Nor do they actually want what they claim, some of them are lying and some don't know how to express themselves, but either way actually taking things women say at face value is foolish.

They don't actually care about how much you make, although it helps. Most women care about the tingle and very little else. The women who don't, the ones who actually care solely about wealth are the predators.

Tall contributes to the tingle. And 5"9' isn't "tall", let's be honest. It's above or about average depending on your race. Is it tallER than most women, sure.