This is a response to this thread: https://scored.co/c/KotakuInAction2/p/17tebxJDjX/
Now that we've seen the result of the return of our mod (not going to name him in the hopes that he doesn't appear) I would like to make the case for simply ignoring him and hoping he goes away.
First, even with the "new tools", nothing has changed. Bad actors are already bypassing them and it's unlikely that these measure will do anything more than embolden our friendly neighborhood subversive.
Second, whenever we get any moderation, it's a carpet bombing operation rather than a surgical strike. Instead of focusing on the actual problem, our mod apparently decided to go through the report queue and start handing out bans to everyone else as well. Not only does this not help, but it'll encourage regulars to start using alts which further muddies the situation.
Finally, and if this gets me banned so be it, we need to talk about the elephant in the room: the Jewish question.
I'm just back from a two-day ban for daring to state that all Jews believe a certain thing in order to be considered Jewish (I don't need to rehash it unless someone wants details). Note this is not an identity attack, it's an attack on religious beliefs and I made that clear.
While I was out, I was lurking. There were front page posts deriding niggers, faggots, and mudslimes (using those terms), that are still up right now (not to mention Imp being reinstated). At least one of those is an identity group and another is a religion. I did nothing that isn't done here on a regular basis, by regulars, especially during this whole Yasuke thing. But I got banned because muh auntie semetism. The mod used the classic "they're a race when they're criticised, but a religion when justifying their own atrocities" schtick. I had the exact same conversation with fishyman when he got modded on gaming, but even he had the integrity to consider my points instead of silencing me; let that sink in.
I'm not saying the mod is jewish but, to paraphrase u/then's Law: Any forum that doesn't explicitly call out subverters, will be subverted.
Either our mod gives the jewish faith preferential treatment, or he's simply responding to the highest volume of reports which is the same as handing your authority over to the most moralizing, backbiting, subversive users on the board; need I say more?
Regardless, our mod cannot be trusted to appoint any other mod. I know he likes conspiracies, so here's one: maybe he refuses to appoint another mod because he knows that none of the oldfags here are actually (((subverters))) and so he's planning on grooming some new accounts that he can instate later on?
Probably not. He's probably just disinterested. But that just means he'll appoint whoever makes the most pleasant noises at him when he should be appointing his critics, who actually care about the board.
My proposal is: ignore him.
Don't yell at him, don't mention him, don't even report posts (just gives him cover to say "well, you didn't report this post"). Every user should check New (daily, if possible) and downvote the spam to oblivion. Downvote spam comments but only reply with "Ban - reason". Anything actually illegal should be reported to site admins. With any luck, we can get this place declared abandoned and someone else can slip in. If not, at least regulars stop getting arbitrarily banned with nothing to show for it.
The nuclear option is always to migrate, but we've got a good thing going here (despite him): a vibrant, free-speech, culture war forum, with diverse opinions. I'd like to keep it that way.
Imagine thinking that 80iq congolese playing with ai image generation are to blame for a French company saying that there were black samurais in Japan
https://communities.win/c/KotakuInAction2/p/17txMTCYyo/blacks-are-using-ai-to-convince-/c
Imagine thinking you need to post graphic footage of a white woman being beaten by an african in order to laugh at marvel being a dei shitshow:
https://communities.win/c/KotakuInAction2/p/17txMTCHvq/x/c
Posts like these degrade the forum. Everyone should be opposed to degrading the forum, regardless of your beliefs on the modern world’s social issues
Cheers man thanks for being reasonable (and thanks for getting me to expand my point enough that it made sense)
For real, it’s the equivalent of “mental junk food”, and it’s a fact that there are “junk food pushers” out there who have the goal of sliding/degrading forums into irrelevance. They’re trying to give us diabetes so we all end up with our legs amputated lol.
My issue mostly comes down to how problems are being framed here lately, usually I agree with a/the core nugget of the points, but they’re so often being framed in a way that neglects nuance and context, which frames something that could be a productive discussion as more of a blackpill take-it or leave-it situation
I will say I doubt most are doing it maliciously, but I simultaneously think there are a group of “seeders” who are acting maliciously. We saw it* happen to 4chan, 8chan, reddit, theDonald, ConPro and I’m sure a bunch of forums I never bothered with. These seeders, through astroturfing votes and responses, basically change the collective consciousness of the forum through subverting the old and replacing it with the new.
it* meaning “forum sliding with the goal of neutering discussion”, because while the overarching pattern is the same, different forums with different ethos’ require different means of subversion. On the Chans it was most often porn, here it more often takes the form of ragebait/“mental junk food”
What I would most like about this hypothetical is that it could open things up for more discussion of the good things in life. We all know what we hate these days, it’s rubbed in our faces constantly. I think we could do with more reminders of what we love, what’s beautiful still… I think the main point should be balance. Maybe this whole subject deserves a meta post in the future for the community to actually consciously direct ourselves?